HN is one of my favorite places on the internet - the themes, the people and the tone are really cool. But the ephemeral nature of posts is not good for discussing ideas. Threads for debating ideas in depth should last forever, as they did in forums.
I wish HN launched a forum feature, or that someone built something in parallel and they saw a massive influx from the HN community.
If someone has ideas on how to pull this off I’d be happy to contribute - I can design and code full-stack. My requirement to hop on board would be that we somehow manage to tie it to the HN values, themes and audience - I wouldn’t be so interested in an ex-novo community-building exercise.
Maybe we could start with some structured discovery work, gathering opinions from existing HN users - we know where to find them! - and take it from there.