X is hard, only people can do it. X requires intelligence. A computer doing X is AI.
AI researcher programs a computer to do X
Oh, X isn't AI, it's just [describe what AI researcher did]. That's not real AI.
X is hard, only people can do it. X requires intelligence. A computer doing X is AI.
AI researcher programs a computer to do X
Oh, X isn't AI, it's just [describe what AI researcher did]. That's not real AI.
> Researcher Rodney Brooks complains: "Every time we figure out a piece of it, it stops being magical; we say, 'Oh, that's just a computation.'"
Instead, for-profit companies seem to have let their marketing departments move the goal-posts to the 40-yard line. "We can't build real machine intelligence, so we'll call this AI."
For me, I always thought R2D2 or R. Daneel Olivaw were what AI was supposed to be. Not "playing Go is hard, so a computer program that can do that is AI." It's the AI label that has been misapplied.
I know, this is where I get the lecture about words meaning different things over time. It's why the technical term for the stuff we've been talking about is Machine Learning systems, not "AI." The "AI" phrase is marketing fluff.
For any reasonable definition of understanding, we have. If you wanted to test my understanding of an article after reading it, what would you ask me? Now submit the same articles to ChatGPT and ask the same questions. I'm not sure who would score better.
The ability to generate text from statistical models of text is not understanding. That we can fool vision systems with decals is because those vision systems cannot bring a model of the world to bear on the interpretation of the statistical matches coming in through the detectors.
We've built Chinese rooms able to supply gibberish and excellent translation with equal aplomb.
Ask a cocky undergraduate philosophy student to BS you about how 2 + 2 = 5, and they will confidently do the same.
What’s your point?