Counter-point, I moved from Liberty Mutual because when I switched from a heavy pickup truck to a cheaper compact SUV with more safety features, my rate went UP, against all reason. Multiple customer service agents refused to look into why that was the case. I got quotes from four other companies -- the most expensive quote was still 1/2 the price Liberty Mutual was giving me. The plan I went with was 1/3rd the price. I'm saving $3,000 a year. And Progressive hasn't spam called me even once.
Everyone seems to have horror stories about ALL the companies out there.