Copyrights: Feds push a few novel theories in MegaUpload case
opinion.latimes.com
opinion.latimes.com
Except bandwidth costs money. Was MegaUpload really able to recoup the bandwidth costs of a full-length movie with ads?
I guess they're trying to be thorough or something, but probably 2/3rds of the indictment is pointless and the real complaints are hidden by a lot of insinuations that sound ridiculous.
I think you're overestimating the cost of bandwidth.
Let's say a full length movie is 4 GB. I can get a server with 30 TB of monthly data transfer for $40 a month. That's 75 cents a terabyte, or 0.3 cents per full length movie. That's not outrageous.
Given the scale of MegaUpload's operation, they would probably be paying considerably less for their bandwidth.
Although if you're looking for something more well known, 100tb will sell you a box with 100tb/mo on a gigabit connection for $200 a month
Not totally unreasonable, but five times higher (400% higher) than the number you quoted. So, back to the numbers - that's 1.5cent per full length movie -- and they're probably getting something like $0.40 CPM == 400 microusd; Assuming they show 10 ads per download, that means they get 4 milliusd per download; slightly higher than the cost you assumed, but almost 25% of the cost at the link you provided.
Even if they get it much cheaper, something still doesn't add up here -- unless most of their downloads are not full length movies (e.g. tv shows, songs, pdf files) - in which case it makes much more sense.
[edited: corrections]
Honestly, that's probably the biggest thing to watch. If they come up with some particular rule, a lot of people will have to scramble to implement something. And it will be even worse if they just say that people need one without giving any guidance.
I hope to see remarks from grellas on this one.
EDIT: Note that they do mention the repeat infringers bit the "conspiracy" section of the indictment, but that doesn't really make things very clear. I note that they also claim a link to ninjavideo (whose owner was taken down for criminal infringement) at the very start, then leave it out when talking about the "conspiracy." Weird.
Megaupload wasn't private storage, it was public storage. A musician wanting to distribute songs for free can either buy bandwidth or can host the file on MegaUpload. Joe Sixpack (in Alabama) can host the Christmas family videos for his sisters in Australia and England.
But I'd really want to see figures for how much material was copy vio vs non copyvio. And I want to be prepared for how that information is going to be presented; byte size? number of files?
If the majority of MegaUploads revenues came from clicks/views of ads on downloads of illegal content, then I'd say the government's assertions are correct.
Kind of hard to make 150MM with a few paid users uploading/downloading own content.
It makes it that much easier for a prosector to convince the jury of a conspiracy...by Mega Conspiracy.