That said I'd argue the culture war is quasi-religious, and it's being fought equally across the Anglosphere and beyond.
That said I'd argue the culture war is quasi-religious, and it's being fought equally across the Anglosphere and beyond.
It seems to me like the reason Germany doesn’t have a religiously charged debate on abortion is that no major party is pushing for abortion to 24 weeks or even later like in America.
It doesn't seem unreasonable that other people would have a lower comfort limit, again even without religion.
If you want to see what atheists do when they’re not bound by the cultural hangover of an abrahamic religion, look at population control efforts in Asia. The Chinese correctly observed that, from a purely utilitarian standpoint, there’s no compelling reason to draw the line at birth.
Except there is. You want the same protections applied to you, even if you're unconscious or otherwise unable to protest. Pretty much the only broadly supportable position is that killing a viable person is murder and no more or less supportable than them killing you.
Personally I find his view to be utterly morally abhorrent, but I have to credit him with the courage and consistency of taking utilitarianism to its logical conclusion.
Me. That's why I want to find a simple set of rules that we can both agree to, where you care about me in trade for similar concern and protection.
> If a stroke reduces you to the same level of mental functioning as a newborn
Right, I don't consider that viable without some sort of prognosis of recovery but if we go too far down the line of 'burden to society' it starts to include people who drive too slowly in the passing lane and gets more subjective.