On NixOS: I generally agree, though it can be tricky to get that done with NixOS. I bet we can make some inroads there.
Easy questions:
> idempotent
It isn't currently idempotent, but we're working on "curing" which brings some idempotency to it, and allows for "rescuing" installations that aren't working correctly. Curing will also support creating a JSON document for installs that don't already have one.
> profitable company or just a group of Nix believers
We are a for-profit company, and we are a group of Nix believers :).
Bash:
Bash is really hard to get right, and really hard to make fast, and really hard to extend its featureset to more complicated use cases. We could "just" download a bash, but when we're trying to navigate disk encryption and APFS volumes and mounts ... it is quite a lot easier to write and test that code in a "bigger" language.
Also note that it isn't just Bash that we'd need to download, but coreutils and other utilities that Bash is really built on top of. We tried to fix a pretty simple bug last year in the Bash installer, and it took two weeks to validate a relatively straightforward, one line change was valid on all the platforms we target.