Florida bill would make bloggers who write about governor register with state
arstechnica.com
arstechnica.com
Especially after hearing non-stop about the supposed free-speech concerns of a twitter algorithm that they were convinced was partially benefiting one side more than the other. Something trivial in scope and still not entirely clear was actually happening - here we have actual insane free speech authoritarian concerns and it's crickets.
You must register with the state before speaking out against a government authority, or will be fined daily if you don't.
So much complaining about why can't they use the n-word more often and yet when it comes to actual serious immensely consequential free-speech concerns from a potential leading presidential candidate nothing.
The hypocrisy is unbearable at this point. No different than Elon the supposed free speech proponent whose main act has been to ban people speaking out against him.
> Especially after hearing non-stop about the supposed free-speech concerns of a twitter algorithm that they were convinced was partially benefiting one side more than the other.
They’re frauds. It was never about protecting free speech. It was about protecting speech that they like.
Edit: oh good https://www.thefire.org/news/fire-statement-florida-senate-b...
Really has nothing to do with speech at all, and everything to do with appearing anti woke. Posturing.
When it comes time to spin it, itll be sold as "put an end to under the table woke lobbying"
This proposed law is obviously un-American, and may not hold up to judicial scrutiny.
Edit: it may not even hold up to public scrutiny!
The fact that its blatantly unconstitutional makes even more hypocritical from a party who regularly claim unconditional allegiance to this document.
Bills like this aren't meant to pass on the first go. They are just testing the waters. But its existence is clear evidence of what they really want. Same goes for that bill that, if enacted, would eliminate the democratic party [0] or the bills that did get passed which is letting Desantis exert control over Disney, with the stated goal of making a private company change its content to what he favours. Viewed collectively they show a coherent pattern.
[0] https://www.nbcnews.com/politics/politics-news/florida-repub... [1] https://nymag.com/intelligencer/2023/03/desantis-promises-fl...
Right now, it wouldn't pass with a Republican House, or (given the supermajority requirement to propose an amendment) with a narrowly Democratic Senate. It might not even pass with a widely Democratic Senate; the California legislature failed to pass a bill on this despite a wide Democratic majority.
And it wouldn't be ratified by the required supermajority of states, because lots of states are heavily invested in penal labor.
Outrage over Florida beign extreme on this might make it help polarize Dem states (via the Dem electorate) against it even where instituttionally entrenched, but that would be offset by the effecg of polarizing the issue on the other side.
Conservatism consists of exactly one proposition, to wit: There must be in-groups whom the law protects but does not bind, alongside out-groups whom the law binds but does not protect.
They want the law to protect conservative speech, but not bind it. They want the law to bind moderate and liberal speech, but not protect it.
As someone in a minority group that Desantis is specifically going after, I don't really find it very fascinating, more terrifying.
> this only applies to bloggers who are being paid to blog
So uhh... is it really free speech if you're getting paid to speak? I would argue not so. I would argue: if you're getting paid to speak then you're neither speaking freely in the "free as in free beer" nor the "free as in free speech" interpretations of free.
I see no carve out about being paid. Your reasons for your speech are your own, you shouldn’t be forced to register to voice opinion about a government official even if you’re employed to give opinions. This stuff isn’t about transparency in government like lobbyist rules. It’s about intimidated critics, which is precisely the reason the first amendment was deemed necessary.
Yes.
Either it's the writer's speech, or it's that of whoever is paying for it.
"and there was no one left to speak for me."
Ron Desantis owns FL politics.
Edit: Honestly I wrote all of that forgetting about the subject matter of the bill. You can’t possibly believe such a bill, in reality, originated anywhere but the Governor’s office. Come on, nobody is that naive.
Which essentially means that _anybody_ can be "the press," so long as they are doing journalistic things, like reporting and writing about matters of public interest.
You don't need to work for a newspaper, or for anyone other than yourself. You can be an independent or freelance journalist.
You don't need credentials. Indeed, there is not a single government entity in the country that issues credentials indicating whether a person is a member of the press or not. Certain government offices might issue credentials in the form of access to a particular event, but those credentials are about access, not about legitimacy. You can be "the press" even if no one has ever issued you credentials for anything.
And it's worth noting that the line between traditional newspaper journalism and digital journalism via blogging or other online dissemination is not as clear-cut as you might think. Plenty of traditional newspapers publish op-eds and commentary sections, alongside their news sections. And plenty of traditional newspapers frequently update their online editions.
So even if this proposed bill were not a flagrant violation of the First Amendment, it would be really hard to draw a bright line between newspapers and bloggers, for the purpose of enforcement.
And couldn't bloggers/journalists just publish stuff via a hosting service that's located out of state?
Besides, anonymous and pseudonymous bloggers are untargetable by definition, if they take even the laxest efforts to conceal their real identities.
This isn't just a ridiculous law, it seems completely unenforceable in general. The only exception is that it may be useful in harassing or annoying a mere handful of bloggers that are already known to the state.
Courts have a process called "discovery." You can sue a John Doe and then use discovery to find out who you're actually suing[1]. Yes, really. This process could potentially compel hosting services, publishing platforms, ISPs, and so on to provide the information they have.
Once President DeSantis is in office, this will serve as a blue print for a national version of the same state sanctioned harassment laws.
>(d) “Compensation” includes anything of value provided to a blogger in exchange for a blog post or series of blog posts. If not provided in currency, it must be the fair-market value of the item or service exchanged.
>(2) If a blogger posts to a blog about an elected state officer and receives, or will receive, compensation for that post, the blogger must register with the appropriate office, as 163 identified in paragraph (1)(f), within 5 days after the first 164 post by the blogger which mentions an elected state officer.
So this only applies to bloggers who are being paid to blog. If you or I set up a blog and receive no compensation for it, this does not apply to us. Ordinary folks ability to go to blogger, tumblr, substack, wherever and start posting about their local politicians will not be restricted.
[0]https://www.flsenate.gov/Session/Bill/2023/1316/BillText/Fil...
Right! It does change absolutely nothing - you, me, and most people in this thread, assuming we were Florida residents, would still be free to create our own blogs and discuss our politicians on them without fear of legal repercussions pertaining to this bill. :)
>... it’s still ridiculous and unconstitutional. You have free speech rights even if you’re being paid.
It is! And I agree. I just disagree that it "changes absolutely nothing". You could be punished if you're a paid blogger, or unpunished and free to speak your mind if you're not paid. That's worth highlighting, because it further underscores just how absurd this bill is.
Thanks for the clarification, I now understand why you disagreed with me saying “changes absolutely nothing”.
Read the emphasized clause, anyone or any organization that is publishing writing about public figures qualifies as ‘the press’
It means if you happen to have any ads at all on your site, and you receive any kind of payment for displaying those ads, you're being compensated and fall under the category of paid blogger. Similarly, if you're using any ad-supported blogging platform, even if you don't directly receive the ad revenue, it could be argued that you're receiving compensation in the form of free publishing services.
Which means that the only bloggers who would be safe are those who provide their content on a completely ad-free platform, presumably paying all their own hosting costs, and not making a single dime to support themselves in the process.
The funny thing is that people who fall into that category are likely very well-off and don't need to support themselves through their writing or reporting. So, as usual, it's the rich who benefit.
That's not a justification for this proposed law at all to me...
You wrote:
> Ordinary folks ability to go to blogger, tumblr, substack, wherever and start posting about their local politicians will not be restricted.
How do you know this ? How do you know they won’t sue you to disclose your payments or look at your bank accounts
Florida will put you in jail for talking to your wife if you criticize the government
https://theintercept.com/2023/02/05/ron-desantis-florida-vil...
If I failed, cool, but that's why I've asked you to show me where I actively argued in support of this bill. That way I can actively make myself clear in the future.
So here's the explanation.
> Okay, there is a huge detail missing from Ars' report, and a lot of reports about this, that is key here.
You wrote here that there is a huge detail missing that is key. Implying that this missing detail, being so huge, has a change on the proposed law. There is no huge detail at all. Without your clarification they were drastically down on free-speech, with the detail they are drastically clamping down on free speech.
Writing what you wrote implies that if people understood the detail it would be a different situation and there isn't an issue there. That isn't the case. The detail you were referring to was people receiving any payment. Substacks receive compensation, blogs with ads receive compensation, people with afiliate links receive compensation. Saying all of these people have to register with the government first before criticizing it is horrible and just as horrible if it were all bloggers. That is not a critical detail at all.
It's like saying the law comes out and then someone runs up and says "hey everyone is missing a critical detail, it's only restricting people of a specific ethnicity from criticizing the government". That is not a critical detail at all and has no bearing on anything anyone posted. No different than positing "it's only restricting people wearing blue jeans, not everyone." That is not a critical detail, it's an irrelevant detail. And saying it's critical implies that people now need to interpret the law differently an implicitly says it's not as negative as people are saying it is. All of those are wrong.
That's why everyone who is responding to you is saying exactly what they are - because your post is implying (unintentionally apparently) that that detail changes how horrible the proposed law is.
No. There isn't. That's literally mentioned in the article. Fourth paragraph
> (c) The blogger must file reports with the appropriate office using the electronic filing system: 1. As provided in s. 11.0455 if the blog post concerns an elected member of the Legislature; or 2. As provided in s.32155 if the blog post concerns an officer of the executive branch. (d) The reports must include all of the following: 1. The individual or entity that compensated the blogger for the blog post. 2. The amount of compensation received from the individual or entity, regardless of how the compensation was structured. ...
Sorry for the poor formatting I'm on mobile. But if I'm reading this correctly I would be fine with forcing people that get paid by the government to have to publicly disclose that information. But once again, I have no idea if I'm reading it correctly.
So, if somebody pays you to write about the governor, you have to tell the government who paid you.
I think they're trying to allude to the way the FEC requires disclosures about who pays for campaign ads. But they don't require you to register anything, just to make disclaimers. And that applies to all candidates, not just the sitting officials.
https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=35010784
Taken together, it sounds like neither one has a serious intention of passing. It's just a way for them to thump their chests.
If enacted, the proposed law would likely be challenged in court on grounds that it violates First Amendment protections of freedom of speech and the press... Defending his bill, Brodeur said, "Paid bloggers are lobbyists who write instead of talk. They both are professional electioneers. If lobbyists have to register and report, why shouldn't paid bloggers?"
Truly captivating argument from the sponsor of the bill. Florida is so lucky to have him.
and this guy wants to be president
-> The defamation proposals were spurred by DeSantis, who last month held a roundtable discussion on media defamation and called on the legislature "to protect Floridians from the life-altering ramifications that defamation from the media can cause for a person who does not have the means or the platform to defend himself."
"We've seen over the last generation legacy media outlets increasingly divorce themselves from the truth and instead try to elevate preferred narratives and partisan activism over reporting the facts," DeSantis said. "When the media attacks me, I have a platform to fight back. When they attack everyday citizens, these individuals don't have the adequate recourses to fight back. In Florida, we want to stand up for the little guy against these massive media conglomerates."
https://www.orlandosentinel.com/politics/os-ne-brodeur-semat...