Perhaps I'm ignorant of other aspects/solutions. But this is my take with being solely responsible for access to my own funds.
Perhaps I'm ignorant of other aspects/solutions. But this is my take with being solely responsible for access to my own funds.
Most people are unbanked not because banks don’t exist for them but because they don’t have money to put into an account. In the US online banks like Ally or Schwab are way better for folks who are legitimately unbanked than a crypto wallet - esp one they are unlikely to properly custody. Postal banking is an approach that has been historically hugely successful too.
Outside the US honestly I don’t know how folks wouldn’t be better served with for instance access to an account at circle.com vs USDC.
People not having money is a social problem that deserves a meaningful social solution - not digital magic beans.
Not true at all, as the GP explicitly mentions Shamir's secret sharing:
> Shamir's secret sharing (SSS) is an efficient secret sharing algorithm for distributing private information (the "secret") among a group so that the secret cannot be revealed unless a quorum of the group acts together to pool their knowledge. To achieve this, the secret is mathematically divided into parts (the "shares") from which the secret can be reassembled only when a sufficient number of shares are combined.
* https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Shamir%27s_secret_sharing
So you can trust various persons / entities such that m out of n need to come together before the secret is revealed. And each person doesn't need to have just one share out of n: if you trust one person more that you can give them two (or more) shares out of the n.
The irony, lol.
If you don’t want to manage a wallet, just use Coinbase.
A similar problem arises under other circumstances. And yes, there are off-the-shelf solutions now, eg: https://bitwarden.com/help/emergency-access/
Technically, "I forgot the key" access is not a difficult problem to solve. And because of they have digital contracts as part of their DNA, crypto currencies provide all the tools you need to solve it even without things like Bitwarden.
You are right about there being no "banks" in one aspect though. While there are any number of solutions out there to the crypto-currency key problem and some will do a better job than a bank, there is no easy and low risk way to find the solution that works for you. Certainly nothing remotely as easy and low risk as "walk into any USA bank and open an account". The real magic of a conventional bank is not all the protections in place (who hasn't been screwed over by a bank or credit card company at some point?), it is that it is a "well understand, everybody knows about it" convention.
No, not really. It is the same kind of story as people putting all their money in a bag in a chimney to find out their family decided to finally lighten the mood by making a fire in long unused fireplace. It is an actual story about my neighbour when I was a kid.
People have been doing stupid things with money for thousands of years.
You can store crypto safely. It is essentially the same problem as storing encrypted backups. It has been solved.
As much as I hate cryptocurrency, I would actually be more at peace having lots of crypto than lots of stock on my account (if not for the fact that crypto is just a scam).
Something to keep in mind when talking to people about these ideas, they’re usually paired with some “apes together strong” kind of magnanimous idealism, where the community/market would come up with solutions.
This guy is using one solution from nearly 10 years ago, and it has some user experience issues
all the UX improvements are developed in bear markets, and they onboard the next million users that help result in the next bull market
look at argent.xyz
When we don't want to be responsible with cash, we give it to a bank. Same with BTC.