To contain China, chips shouldn’t be seen as “advanced” or “less advanced”
csis.org
csis.org
That said, the article isn't wrong: if you believe the risk is solely future chips you've really misunderstood the depth of IPR in existing chips.
There is already a far more fundamental economic asymmetry.
China’s intellectual property regime is different. Their government steals IP on behalf of their private sector.
Their relationship between government and private sector is very different. Specifically, their laws are far more malleable to the interpretation of officials and are less objectively factual. They will hold businessmen and tourists hostage to gain leverage in business deals or diplomatic negotiations.
That said, I don’t think there’s value in restricting all tech or all chips. Military-specific single purpose? Yes. Bleeding edge semiconductor manufacturing tech? Maybe. Commodity RFID, Bluetooth, WiFi chips? I don’t see any value except to create arbitrary shocks to the supply chain and force tech companies to add redundancy to their suppliers (which has already happened).
you mean like this? https://contextisking.com/2021/02/06/the-paradox-of-hollywoo...
or maybe like this? https://victorianweb.org/authors/dickens/pva/pva74.html
Seems like pretty standard stuff. We've just pulled the ladder up after ourselves with the export of the US copyright regime via trade agreements.
In practice, Chinese companies don’t use IP and have much closer to perfect market competition. The Chinese government chooses not to enforce what IP they have on the books, suggesting it only exists for the purposes of homogenizing with international trade treaties.