Hacker News Reader

I mean, that is what it's for. It's about making someone else's argument fit into your own system without misrepresenting it or making it unclear.

I suppose having "steelman" lets you relate it to "strawman" and "weakman" which can be an advantage, but knowing the existing term lets you read the existing literature.

View on HN

> making someone else's argument fit into your own system without misrepresenting it or making it unclear

I think this is where steelman is a superset of this, in that it includes the reconstruction definition but also includes making a whole new set of arguments that are entirely unrelated to your own argument or the other person's argument. i.e. Steelmanning can involve coming up with novel arguments for the other side.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com