I'd say 3.
> Beyond congestion, what'd the worst you can do to a ISP?
Nothing much, which is why that exception is not very strong.
> Beyond congestion, what'd the worst you can do to a ISP?
Nothing much, which is why that exception is not very strong.
If the law uses the words "purposely harm the network" instead of "harm the network" then it's harder to claim it applies to services that e.g. increase congestion by sending a lot of legitimate data. Being clearer narrows the scope of the excuses their lawyers can emit.
What's needed is a way for recipient endpoints to tell upstream networks that they (temporarily) don't want traffic from particular sources. But that requires a new network protocol, not some arbitrary policy judgement on the part of random ISPs.