However, this is balanced by the legal protection offered to the company when it does do something that does not strictly increase its profits.
It comes down to your values though -- if you believe that the most important thing is to make money while leaving yourself open to the smallest cross-section of legal liability, that's exactly what a standard corporation is for. If you believe that your purpose is to build a better world, and you need an organization with cashflow to do it, you had fewer options in the past. Now you have two more, at least in California.
If you wanted to make profits and to build a better world, what prevented you from setting a regular company and a charity and have the former donate to the latter? A lot of people donate millions of dollars this way.
It looks like it's one of those feel-good laws that everybody pats themselves on the backs about how they promoted public benefit and nobody even thinks about how it would work or what would be the consequences...
The better and more important question would be whether they were put in a benchmark like the Russell 1000 since it would force mutual funds to consider whether they should own it.
All public companies are C corporations. I'm trying to see if there is a requirement in the SEA or NYSE listing standards that mandate, this, but given the NYSE's requirement of fiduciary responsibility to shareholders, B corps produce a legal conflict of interest.
Will the B Corp legal framework create additional liability for our Board of Directors and officers?
It is the opinion of our attorneys that adopting the B Corp legal framework to expand the definition of the ‘best interests’ of the corporation should reduce the liability for Directors and Officers by creating legal protection (called ‘safe harbor’) for them to take into consideration the interests of multiple stakeholders when making decisions, particularly when considering financing and liquidity scenarios. Adopting the B Corp legal framework will, however, give shareholders additional rights to hold Directors and Officers accountable for taking into consideration these same interests when making decisions ‐‐ and that of course is the whole point.
From the FAQ for investors and directors: http://www.bcorporation.net/resources/bcorp/documents/FAQs%2....
In your particular scenario involving SOPA/PIPA, the company's executives can straightforwardly claim that they acted in good faith to promote the interests of the broader business sector that they are a part of, and thus they would not be liable for their actions.
If, however, this provision is not toothless and useless, then I don't see how it can not create additional potential liability. Of course, it can play both ways - i.e. the management can both claim public good as defense for controversial actions and be attacked on public good grounds for them. It's just an additional complication, compounded by absence of any clarity on the question of what the said good is.
It is telling that your document does not give a clear answer to the question of additional liability, basically saying "we're reducing liability, no, wait, we're increasing it and it's a good thing!".