That is whole reason for having regulations and goverment audits.
That is whole reason for having regulations and goverment audits.
Shareholders can and should be wiped out with very little to show for it. That is the risk they run.
Demand deposit holders getting wiped out is unthinkable. Taking any non-negligible haircut on their demand deposits (yes, even over $250k) will destroy confidence in the banking industry. This is far worse than the moral hazard of a bailout.
What must be done is not a corporate bailout to protect shareholders, yet tons of people think this is "socializing losses and privatizing gains."
Plus it is not just that shareholders took risk, it is also that market incentives push companies into too rules breaking and too much riks. Because it makes shares go up temporarily.
Says who? 2/3 of amercians live paycheck-to-paycheck [1]. The only thing that a banking system has to provide them is day-to-day operations plus a small cushion (much smaller than 250k).
For that people accumulating over 250k is a privilege, one thay may as well come with the risk of getting it wiped out in very rare events such as this one.
[1] https://www.prnewswire.com/news-releases/23-of-the-us-popula...
> yet tons of people think this is "socializing losses and privatizing gains."
Think about the 2/3rds of americans above. Why shouldn't they think that?
Because:
> 2/3 of amercians live paycheck-to-paycheck [1].
Their paychecks are drawn from these demand deposit accounts.
This money above $250k is not being stored in an account like Scrooge McDuck just trying to get the highest score. This money is being held in a transitive fashion to pay employees, vendors, and lines of credit. This is what people are not understanding.
they are already going to guarantee most accounts anyway.
Hmm it definitely wouldn’t have anything to do with SVB executives wooing VCs with lavish perks and favorable terms to increase deposits though right? That’s definitely not how the industry works.
Anywho - they are still victims and they should be made whole with remaining assets after FDIC makes depositors hole (which is a tiny percentage of deposits at SVB) - no doubt about that, but beside that these businesses and VCs are sophisticated and able to take on and assess risk. They were all calling to remove assets and urging portfolio companies to do the same because they understand the game. Not a lot of regular folks at SVB were. There’s a clear difference in sophistication. Next time maybe they’ll bank across a few organizations to reduce risk. Or maybe ask questions even.
If you’re going to use taxpayer dollars to bailout these businesses in excess of remaining assets you may as well pay lifetime salaries for the employees who worked at SVB. Don’t see a big difference there. I wouldn’t support either action.