If a person is on the verge of bankruptcy and they get a cash infusion that saves them, they have not magically become a pyramid scheme. The fact that money helps fix a massive financial problem does not indicate something is a pyramid scheme, just that they have a massive financial problem.
There is a very specific definition and it is not “ Any system that requires new clients to pay for existing clients’ outflows”
They needed new startups to bring in new cash to make up for the cash burn of their current startup customers.
This is a textbook Ponzi structure. Not criminal, just a totally irresponsible bet on interest rates staying close to 0 for another 10 years.
It's irresponsible to paint ordinary accepted business models that have been in place for hundreds of years and that work fine the vast majority of the time with a criminal brush.
If you think SVB is a regular bank practicing accepted business models I'm not sure you appreciate how unusual SVB is in terms of their customer base and interest rate exposure.
> Regular banks don't have the problem of having billions of dollars in deposits but no way to put that money to work
SVB chose a way to put that money to work, but they miscalculated what would happen to the bond market. I don't know how or why they overexposed themselves to this risk, but I'm fairly certain it wasn't some decision made without the review of numerous investing and risk experts.
SVB was not a fly-by-night operation. It was founded over 40 years ago. My first paychecks from the startup I worked for during the dot-com 1.0 era were drawn from them.
VC investment is highly sensitive to interest rates. Always has been, and everybody knows this. Instead of hedging against this risk SVB decided to double down on it and bet the bank on interest rates going back to zero. I'm sure they had a bunch of risk experts sign off on it, but we both know that doesn't mean anything. Complacency sets in after 15 years of low interest rates, and I think it's exactly because SVB did so well in the ZIRP environment that they got careless.
Isn't it true of any bank that experiences a sudden and unexpected flood of withdrawals that they need an infusion of cash to cover them? Whether they get the cash from new depositors or by liquidating investments, the cash has to come from somewhere.
I think you're mistaking a bad investment decision for a criminal act and intent, and nobody is claiming SVB of a crime at this point in time; the evidence isn't there so far. Every bank invests cash deposits in a mix of liquid and illiquid investments, and the illiquid investments often can't be liquidated quickly, if at all. (Think mortgages.) As I said, that is the business model of a bank.
That doesn't look good.