I am all for FDIC insuring accounts, and I'm fine with the level being as high as $250k. But anybody with a lot of cash beyond that should already understand what the word "uninsured" means. If they don't my sympathy for them is limited.
If we're going to spend billions more on improving the social safety net, people with hundreds of thousands of dollars in cash just lying around are not my first priority.
When people choose where to bank their millions of dollars, they are making a market-based choice. Markets only work when, on balance, good choices get good results and bad choices get bad results. If people can make risky choices and still make money because other people bail them out, that creates a moral hazard.
It incentives ignoring risks from grey/black swan events. Weak analogue, a CTO comes in who removes redundancy/backups from the system, saves huge costs and gets huge bonuses. Once every 5 years system fails and data is lost, CTO loses bonus but on average he is making more.
For people managing millions of dollars, though, I think they should, y'know, do their jobs and make professional-grade risk management decisions. Especially when the alternative is taxpayers coughing up money to subsidize their mistakes.
It's small though and I'm surprised there hasn't been more talk of it and other optional deposit insurance. What does this landscape look like for large companies routinely doing millions in payroll? You can't tell me they sweep it all in/out of different banks in 250k chunks. There has to be some sort of widely used insurance offerings, no?
There's a really nice threshold for measuring this: if you have more cash than can be spread conveniently amongst a number of banks such that those account balances do not exceed FDIC insurance limits, you do need to pay attention to what your bank is doing.
Please. This is not a serious argument.
You could say absolutely the same thing about buying stocks. By your logic, nobody should be allowed to buy stocks because it's just too darned complicated.
Similarly, it is quite literally -- and I do mean this literally -- impossible for anyone to conduct a meaningful and ongoing analysis of their bank.
This leaves basically three options:
* Buy private insurance, which is a fool's errand, as there's no guarantee it would make you whole in the event of a major black swan event.
* Split your account up into an absurd number of institutions. (You get FDIC insurance only per depositor, per account category, per institution. You can't open more accounts of the same category at the same institution).
* Place all your money at one of the Systemically Important Banks, where you basically get unlimited insurance.
Please explain what you thin the rational thing to do here is.
Anyhow, yes, buying stocks is too complicated to be a sure thing. But rather than banning the process, we just make sure there are decent guardrails so the average Joe doesn't get too screwed and systemic risk is limited, and then we let people do a capitalism if they want, but on their own heads be it. And whole industries have risen up to help them do it.
It's the same deal with banks. The government's job isn't to hold the hands of people trying to figure out what to do with their millions. It's to protect the small players from predation and limit systemic risk.
I am not a professional in this field, so I'm not going to pretend to give one-size-fits-all prescriptions for something that is obviously complex and context specific. Instead, I will encourage all fellow founders and would-be founders that there are many things where they should just hire an expert. Like law, or regulatory compliance, or the best way to manage millions in cash.
Just spitballing here, but since apparently a lot of people with millions of dollars who have heard their whole lives about FDIC-insured deposit limits are suddenly waking up to the fact that things above the line are uninsured, seems like a good time to innovate.
Back in 2008, the FDIC launched the Transaction Account Guarantee Program to provide unlimited insurance to uninsured deposits in non-interest bearing accounts, and then later expanded to low interest accounts, on an emergency basis.
This program protected nearly a trillion dollars in uninsured deposits, and made all of them whole.
After Dodd-Frank, the program was ended. However, if the FDIC deems a situation to have systemic risks, it's within their statutory authority to do this again. And it now seems the Government is planning to do exactly that, should they be unable to find a buyer for SVB.
That program was an always-temporary response to a major financial crisis. I expect most finance professionals knew that it was temporary.
But suppose you're right. Suppose all the cool kids thought they'd get bailed out no matter what. In that case, it's even more important now to not use taxpayer money to prevent the big-money SVB accountholders from taking a haircut. Because your justification here is exactly the kind of moral-hazard problem that regulators are very eager to prevent.
If the industry wants a program like that, they can create it. Indeed it already exists: https://www.difxs.com/DIF/Home.aspx
But depositors obviously have the ability to gauge risk, especially sophisticated depositors with millions of dollars of cash lying around. Otherwise people wouldn't be squawking right now about the risk of money being moved out of certain banks to certain other banks. Otherwise things like the DIF wouldn't exist. Otherwise treasury management wouldn't be a whole profession.
The problem is that many depositors are not looking just for safety, they pick other things, sometimes over that. Which is their right! But sometimes when trade safety for other things, it turns out badly for them.
Do you think all the CFO’s, accountants, and financial advisors of American industry didn’t know that until this weekend?
Yet the small and regional banks still seemed to have made it all this time.
I was aware of this regulation. I thought it was unlikely. But now that it is happened, I will be removing all my money from smaller banks over to TD (big Canadian bank).