The value judgement that was done here is that if they didn't do it this bank collapse would generate contagion, which I believe is understandable, however if that is the case there should be other ways to prevent this kind of thing such as regulation that prevents banks from putting customer deposits into mortgage-backed securities (what the actual fuck, I still can't believe they've done this, it's like the world has learned nothing from 2008).
Specifically I note that around 2018 there was regulation passed that reduced the amount of scrutiny banks such as Sillicon Valley Bank would receive [0], which we all know now how well that worked. Everyone needs to be taken accountable to the same degree, there should be no special cases or "exceptions". And if a need for those appears that should indicate a systemic problem instead of simply a isolated one-time event.
[0]: https://www.forbes.com/sites/mayrarodriguezvalladares/2023/0...
To which someone like would you say "but who's paying for that? the other banks? and guess where their money comes from?
Again, regardless of your political stance or economical, I recommend you read the linked Forbes article about the "Reform Act" I linked to previously [0].
[0]: https://www.forbes.com/sites/mayrarodriguezvalladares/2023/0...
That also doesn't count possible insider trading for recent stock sales.
And then a bunch of small business fail, then everyone else looks at 20 other small and middle-tier banks and realizes they don't want to end up the same way and pull their money out, then they fail, per your suggestion FDIC still does nothing, then another couple dozen banks and couple thousand business fail ...and next week you're back in 2008.
That is already in motion. Every company that had yet to do it is now looking into its liquidity management.
> And then a bunch of small business fail, then everyone else looks at 20 other small and middle-tier banks and realizes they don't want to end up the same way and pull their money out, then they fail
Why the hell should a bank fail if people take their money out of it? THAT's the problem. It's just not a thing in other parts of the world _even with fractional banking_. The fact a "bank run" can generate losses for depositors is simply a consequence of a lack of regulation. The further fact this can generate a "contagion" is a consequence of the banking system simply not hedging their investments correctly and not applying simple risk-management mechanisms, and they do it for the same reason: lack of regulation that keeps the accountable.Again, this kind of problem simply doesn't exist elsewhere. Just look outside the United States and the solution is simple: either you deregulate or you regulate, you can't have your cake and eat it too.
Any account used for business operating expenses needs to be mandated to have premium insurance on it. That same insurance should be available for all depositors.
The next time this happens if you do not have that insurance you receive your receivership certificate and wait for your dividends. Like everyone else.
I'm not saying prevent the contagion is a bad thing. We all know what happens when contagion becomes a systemic problem (2008). What I'm suggesting is that the fact a bank like this can even fail in a way like this is absurd. I'm mostly someone who defends less regulation over more, but if we are going to regulate banks we need to hold everyone to the same standards, and make sure everyone is accountable for their mistakes and risks taken. If that requires the FDIC raising the amount of deposits that are insured, sure, go with it, but creating "exceptions" every time a medium-sized bank fails is sure to create moral problems, corruption and increase inequality systematically.
What I'm talking about is thing such as the "Reform Act" from 2018, which was basically what allowed this Silicon Valley Bank disaster to happen [0].
[0]: https://www.forbes.com/sites/mayrarodriguezvalladares/2023/0...
As to "exceptions", there isn't any exception here. Standard practice in every bank collapse after IndyMac has been that depositors (including uninsured depositors) are made whole. It's just not something the FDIC will commit to because they don't want to commit to making depositors whole and be on the hook if an obviously risky and disreputable bank collapses and depositors want their money back.
> Owners of unsecured debt and investors are left out. Which is fine by me.
Also fine by me.The distinction I attempted to make in my comment was that there are actually something like four parties in this case: Holders of debt, investors, insured deposits and uninsured deposits. I find it absurd the FDIC is going to realize a loss to cover uninsured deposits, because that's simply not what they should do if they followed their own standard. Remember, even though it's state-owned the FDIC is a company, Americans should be worried if the FDIC takes actions that could ultimately put in risk money that _is_ actually insured. If they run dry, they will have to tap into the government's pockets and that's when shit truly hits the fan.
Oh, I know this one! https://breckyunits.com/the-great-bank-robbery.html
What's going on here is the fed is deciding that certain creditors are too big to fail.