Why go to all that trouble to fight the FBI if you still have your files? Doubly so if these folks were some kind of pirates, because that's sort of like painting a giant target on their back.
Why go to all that trouble to fight the FBI if you still have your files? Doubly so if these folks were some kind of pirates, because that's sort of like painting a giant target on their back.
If that's the case I don't think it would be unreasonable for the FBI to say that anyone having lost files has only themselves to blame as this wasn't any sort of guaranteed storage medium.
That doesn't sound right. Why would a shopping center be liable for someone else's actions, specifically someone hitting your car?
I guess you could claim that the way the parking lot was built didn't provide... enough visibility? Or something? I dunno.
I don't think this works. The files are gone because MU's business model resulted in law enforcement action. So arguably MU's responsible, though they disclaim liability for damages.
It's like if MU stopped paying their hosting services, and those services shut down MU's servers for non-payment. MU's customers wouldn't have any case against the hosting providers. The FBI case is similar.
They're not lost. They're not gone. The FBI has them and they could give them back if they wanted to. I'm not saying they will, just that they could.
Can the FBI give back copies of the data? I'm sure pirate party types wouldn't have a problem with that...
And I suspect that MU's TOS made it clear that they weren't really guaranteeing permanent availability to even premium customers.