Yes, you can die. Yes, it is dangerous. Yes, these brave men risked their lives and they lost. And if they had to do it all over again, they would risk their lives again.
Because if it wasn't for men like them, we would still be sitting in a cave poking a fire with a stick.
Because of them, we now have large sticks which take us to space by poking the Earth with fire. :)
I agree with your entire comment. Think about the explorers of old, crossing oceans and continents, in hazardous conditions, with little technology to aid them, and with even less knowledge of where their journeys would lead. We stand on the brave shoulders of the countless who have come before, and it would be an insult to their accomplishments if we, as humans, suddenly abandoned, in the name of ultimate safety, the wonder of exploration, and the courage required to see it through.
Yet those risks can come with great rewards when they pay off and it is only by accepting those higher risks that society can advance and improve.
>men like them
It wasn't just men:
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Judith_Resnik
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Christa_McAuliffe
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kalpana_Chawla
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Laurel_Clark
Language has power, and using "men" in this context makes invisible the contributions and bravery of these women and others like them. Sorry to seem PC, but it's important to get this stuff right if we want our kids to grow up in a better world.
I understand that "men" is sometimes used in the way you describe, but I believe that people who do so consider male the default gender of humans.
If you want to presume some sort of conspiracy sexist default supremacist undertone in what I wrote, fine, but I think that says more about you than about me.
That's a false dichotomy. Children don't need to watch a shuttle burst into flames in order for science to progress.
Yes, they do. Progress with zero risk of failure is no progress at all. To even attempt progress with zero risk of failure is to ensure that:
1.) You will minimize your progress
2.) You will fail anyway
...As the Shuttle all too ably demonstrated.
The argument "we should not coddle children because science" rings false to me. "Coddling children" is a bit of a strawman; there are things we don't tell children because of their innate immaturity. As are most things, it's a spectrum.
Watching a shuttle explode on TV is not the same as, say, witnessing first-hand the gruesome death of one's own parents at the hands of a psychopath.
I agree that a balance has to be struck, but I think you've lost sight of where that balance is.
I honestly don't know how to incorporate that aspect into the dollar cost/benefit the article proposes.
The damage is in the response, not the event.