Trust after saying this wasn't going to happen again is one thing. The other is that didn't have a few months of foresight. This isn't 2008. Conditions aren't significantly worse than in November, and certainly not in a way that was unforeseeable. This time is also showing how rushed the first round was. No one thought about what work is needed. They just cut people who has a sub-par review 10 months before.
Trusting that he's being honest is half of it. Trusting that he sees a direction for the company and how that fits in the macro environment is the other.