Loyalty is a two way street. Many of us have 'preferred' clients who were there during the earlier days, but you need to remember that you were still working hard providing a service to them before and now. As a business, it's up to both sides to ensure and maintain a worthwhile business relationship, unless you're desperate for the money and are willing to compromise.
A few more points to consider:
* As others have mentioned, $25 is very low for consulting. Try shooting for at least hourly salary * 1.5.
* Think of what rate they would pay your replacement given today's market rates.
* You've likely grown in skill and experience from 4 years ago, so your rate should show it.
* There are other ways to show loyalty, such as market rate with 10% discount or providing a value added service.
* The nitpicking and increased expectations comes naturally when you're taken for granted. At this point there's very little you can do to win.
* Opportunity cost. The time you're investing doing work you feel is inadequate can be found looking for and doing better gigs.