I stole a colleagues lunch once on the first day of a new job. I was running out quick to go to the book store and grab a book at lunch (lol!) and I grabbed the brown bag thinking it was mine. While I was driving, I pulled the sandwich from the bag took a bite and realized it wasn't mine. I was mortified. I went back put the bag minus sandwich back in the fridge with a $20 apologizing profusely in a note.
The woman whose lunch I stole laughed it off and gave me back the money. I was ragged on for the entirety of my 5 years there for stealing that lunch.