Trying to legislate what certain words mean and no one can use a particular word as part of their company name unless it checks certain boxes gets into the "you're trying to regulate that?"
When a business chooses to use a word because it’s deceptive that’s very questionable IMO.
"GPT-4" and "DALL-E" don't use the word open in their description.
The research is accessible. ( https://openai.com/research )
Why are we trying to legislate and regulate the name of a company?
You'll note that even though the company is "Spectrum Organics" the word "organic" doesn't appear on neither the saffron oil nor avocado oil labels.
You can do a search for company names containing "organic" at https://www.sec.gov/edgar/searchedgar/legacy/companysearch.h... and then go and see if they use the word "organic" on their food product labels.
As best as I can tell, you supported their point. Was that your intent?
When you go to https://openai.com you will note that the left most drop down is "research" - not "products"
OpenAI is registered as a research laboratory. It has created a subsidiary corporation that deals with products and profits.
From https://openai.com/blog/introducing-openai
> We’re hoping to grow OpenAI into such an institution. As a non-profit, our aim is to build value for everyone rather than shareholders. Researchers will be strongly encouraged to publish their work, whether as papers, blog posts, or code, and our patents (if any) will be shared with the world. We’ll freely collaborate with others across many institutions and expect to work with companies to research and deploy new technologies.
Does this mean you can have a copy of the model? That is answered in https://openai.com/blog/openai-api
> Why did OpenAI choose to release an API instead of open-sourcing the models?
> There are three main reasons we did this. First, commercializing the technology helps us pay for our ongoing AI research, safety, and policy efforts.
> Second, many of the models underlying the API are very large, taking a lot of expertise to develop and deploy and making them very expensive to run. This makes it hard for anyone except larger companies to benefit from the underlying technology. We’re hopeful that the API will make powerful AI systems more accessible to smaller businesses and organizations.
> Third, the API model allows us to more easily respond to misuse of the technology. Since it is hard to predict the downstream use cases of our models, it feels inherently safer to release them via an API and broaden access over time, rather than release an open source model where access cannot be adjusted if it turns out to have harmful applications.
this chicanery proves that they are being intentionally deceptive.
as for the rest of your post, i have no idea why you copied and pasted some unrelated crap from their website although it does make me wonder if youre using ChatGPT to generate your posts.
that's not what "open" customarily means in the context of software development.
> Why are we trying to legislate and regulate the name of a company?
Nobody on news.ycombinator.com is capable of legislating anything, but to answer your question, it's because the name is deceptive.
And anyways, the names of companies are already "legislated and regulated". If you don't believe me then I dare you to start a new software corporation called Microsoft and see how far you can go before somebody forces you to change it.
[0] https://www.accessdata.fda.gov/scripts/cdrh/cfdocs/cfcfr/cfr...
[1] https://www.ams.usda.gov/about-ams/programs-offices/national...
The use of words like "Open" could signal that the company has a process for 3rd party code auditing. Whether doing it as a matter of government legislation would be a notable benefit for society, I am not sure.
Perhaps an independent global accreditor could be established that does the same. While there may not immediately be penalties for using a protected phrase or word in such a scenario, there is still value in accreditation. People prefer accredited universities and accredited professionals. Over time, countries would delegate the regulation of protected word use to accreditors (as the UK did). Or an accreditor could trademark a phrase or a visual badge, and chase its wrongful users.
But even then, one could argue that this would not be a net benefit to society. How would such an accreditor make money, and would that create barriers to accreditation for good faith actors? We certainly see some of that with some accreditations.
Maybe we should not create more bureaucracy in the world because we believe "open" should mean one thing or another.
[0]https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/incorporation-and...