Not that SDI was going to work, but I will never understand this "we shouldn't build anti-nuke defenses because it might make the people pointing nukes at us angry" attitude.
Not that SDI was going to work, but I will never understand this "we shouldn't build anti-nuke defenses because it might make the people pointing nukes at us angry" attitude.
My personal view is that we should build them to shield from states like the DPRK, but the contrasting view is that it destabilizes Mutually Assured Destruction. We don't know how many of their missiles we'll be able to intercept in the event of a mass strike, so it could make our leaders overly confident to take actions that would escalate. That's the critique, and I think it has some merit, but I also think that there are people that I admire, like Jeffery Lewis, that hold that view or something similar to it.
For whatever it is worth, I've personally worked on arms control and in intelligence, so this opinion is not coming out of the blue.
Further, the way to deal with anti-nuke defenses is to just send more nukes and/or lots of dummies too. Things like iron dome are 90% effective (reportedly, some think that number is too high and has a significant propaganda element)... You dont need a huge success rate for your nukes to be effective. Besides the consequences of a destroyed nuke are not great either, there's still a lot of uranium and plutonium getting dumped into the atmosphere.
If your goal is to end nuclear proliferation, things that increase said proliferation are not ok.
The US is already at a significant disadvantage. Russia's nuke-based nuclear interceptor missiles are an order of magnitude more effective than America's explosive and kinetic-based interceptors.
It was different times, and the overwhelming desire to not escalate or provoke was very real, in a way that just doesn't exist anymore today.
If Reagan finished SDI, other nations like China/Russia could feel the need to develop a similar program. They would at a minimum start researching ways to work around the insanely expensive SDI program, which would cause it to be obsolete.
The cycle continues and everyone loses money and resources that could be spent on other problems.