I wonder if more people have seen the above scene as have seen the original. If not, I wonder if and when the numbers will cross. My kids have seen both, but they probably don't remember seeing the original as they were quite young. I try to force nostalgia film and television on them, but it's hit or miss, and now that they can fight back they won't let me play Indiana Jones films, but are okay with IASIP. (I'd prefer Indiana Jones as it requires less censoring.)
Granted, It's Always Sunny in Philadelphia isn't as popular, and not everyone who has seen one IASIP episode will have seen them all, but the target audience is similar.
The IASIP scene is no where nearly as viral as the Indiana Jones scene anyway. The Indiana Jones clip has higher production value, there’s no talking, it’s shorter, there’s excitement, and a good payoff at the end of it, it has all the ingredients for it to spread across the world no matter what language you speak. It’s timeless, and always relevant.
IASIP drags on, and focuses on school shooters which only resonates with American audiences. They also basically “explain” the entire joke, vs Indiana Jones which simply illustrates it very well.
The arab sword scene will basically be immortal.
The good thing about Indiana Jones is that, because it's set in the past, it doesn't look as dated as an 1981 movie that actually played in 1981 looks. Ok, you can probably guess that it's old if you compare the way Harrison Ford looked then to the way he looks now, but other than that...
And of those, how many are dead because they forgot to bring their gun to the swordfight?
I think I agree, but when I have to rationalize it, I can't really say why!
I only come up with vague things like:
- being made to look like in the past, the visual language is a caricature of the past. This caricature of the 30s has not changed much for us between 1980s and present time.
- which leads to... our present is not as clear as in hindsight (or we haven't formed a caricature of it yet) while it happens
- being set in the past, some of the artefacts of being shot on film, don't stick out as much (in fact, these artefacts are often emulated in modern productions to signal "the past")
- ... as opposed to films set in the future, there are fewer pitfalls
In movie, just before encountering the Arab swordsman Indy fights with his fists quite a few Arabs - and in a few instances it looks like he is going to loose. So discovering at this point that Indy had a firearm all along - and didn't use it even when it appeared to us, the viewers, that he was going to lose - shows us how confident in his abilities he is. And additionally, how aware he is of his own limitations.