I'd love to know the transfer speed differences between SCP, SFTP and FTP - because when I can view both ends of the wire then security is less of a concern than transfer time.
rsync-to-rsyncd over a local link is probably faster though (requires more setup though).
You could probably just pipe tarballs through nc too. ;)
scp and rsync, which is a fantastic companion, allows on-the-fly compression of content to get truly impossible speeds over the wire.
If we have this and it is marketed well then it could replace FTP.
It's slow enough that someone has made 'high performance ssh/scp': http://www.psc.edu/networking/projects/hpn-ssh/