This is definitely a great point! With the context of AI workloads, where critical matmuls are basically of regular large shapes, are there many cases where cutlass/Triton are worse than cuBLAS where we need to throw more GPUs at it?
Speaking of GEMM fusion that you mentioned, flash attention is basically GEMM fusion with online softmax right? This is something I believe really cool and can be made really easy wit a proper abstraction. Say, you may move a chunk of computation under a certain loop and instruct the compiler to optimize data movement or cache intermediate tiles somewhere on chip
Cutlass is supposed to be the first step and to anyone who struggles to understand WTF you're doing when using it, you are not alone. I've seen literally amazing room-silencing stuff with it, but heavy template stuff is really not my thing.
Just like you said, really appreciate that we could actually understand what is going on internally inside the kernel with cutlass, and customize it in a way that cuBLAS doesn't necessarily provide.
Have to agree with you that the template stuff is really annoying. Well, even with some template tricks, the error messages are still less readable, and it is where I think a better abstraction could benefit. Imagine you have an abstraction that simplifies the those threadblocks/warps/etc in a unified way while generalizing it to more backends (AMDGPU, Vulkan, AVX512-VNNI, etc), providing more friendly error messages along compilation given the abstraction is almost certainly more structured than pure c++ code.
I love MLIR and Modular, so please do share more about it! If it’s potential distraction from this thread, I’m also open to email communication if you are interested!
Oh btw, to clarify, I’m not saying Triton is an ideal abstraction. I love it and it’s super popular because it’s the most user-friendly option for ML researchers to write performant kernels on certain gpus, but from a MLSys researcher’s perspective, I’m personally more ambitious and wanted to target broader range of hardwares. Also I really appreciate Philippe’s work that makes Triton really performant and easy to use.