It’s such an odd position. Like, the age old razors / razor blades model should be illegal? Video game consoles / video games?
Subsidizing an initial purchase by charging for ongoing services is so core to our economy that I’m not sure what it would look like to prohibit it.
I imagine a lawyer could convince a jury of people who have never heard of hacker news, gnu, etc that this is true.
The precedent things like this would create could easily be extended to other things. Good lawyers could hold things the OP isn't think about to this standard. Especially if theres a jury uninformed about the topic at hand.
try explaining all this to someone uninterested or uninformed about technology. A cubicle worker or something.
All the effort that surrounds it may be considered a service (often paid, sometimes subsidized). But that's distinct.
People understand very well the product vs service distinction. They notice every time they check their credit card statement.
Anti-dumping laws for well capitalized companies engaging in anti-competitive behavior
sales tax based on the cost of services