GPT-4 is giving me existential crisis and depression
old.reddit.com
old.reddit.com
Before the industrial revolution, people dreamt of the machines coming to take their toil away, to free them to play and enjoy life.
At some point we got lost in our toil and it became our identity and life, we started to live to work.. And now many have been so acclimated to this existence that they cannot even imagine how life could be wonderful without constantly having to work to survive.
An AI can become better than us at everything they do - gaining an absolute productivity advantage - and human labor will still be necessary, and even valuable. It's unintuitive, for sure, but so long as scarcity exists, it remains.
The reason for this is simple: given an AI which can produce two goods, X and Y, faster and better than humans, one might think that all the world's X and Y needs could be satisfied. But this isn't the case, because resources (including time) are finite, and the AI must choose to produce X or Y with any given set of resources (electricity, GPUs, time, whatever). By producing X (which, let's say, it's better at, or is more valuable per unit of resources input), it can achieve optimal absolute output, but this comes at the cost of not producing Y. So long as the demand for Y remains unchanged, there is a need for some other agent to produce Y. This is the human's comparative advantage in Y production.
In short: the total sum of X+Y produced is greater when the AI produces X and the human produces Y, even though the AI is better at producing both, because the AI's opportunity cost of producing Y over X is greater than the cost to import Y from the human. The human can import X from the AI and produce Y and end up with a greater quantity of both than if they tried to create or import both X and Y.
Might this mean a reduction in language-oriented jobs for humans? Certainly, even probably. Retraining and exploration of new careers will be necessary. We can expect jobs to go away, and new jobs to be created; the personal computer and word processor flat out killed the entire typist industry, but created a dizzying array of new opportunities. If you stay still, you'll certainly be left behind, but I don't think we're at the point that we need to worry about human obsolescence any time soon.
(Of course, if we reach the point where all demanded resources can be produced without any effective opportunity cost, then we've achieved post-scarcity, and all bets are off, but that's not anywhere nearly as simple as just cranking a productivity multiplier up.)
Imagine something with 10x the disruptive power.
[1]https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Coal_mining_in_the_United_St....
Also, I am not convinced of the scarcity talk because human labor is them most underutilized scarce resource we have.
In big techs case its less that but more how they will infiltrate governments (just look at the law effectively banning ev cars in a particular state) and potentially create a real oligarchy.
I think that only happens to somebody prone to depression anyway. If it wasn't GPT-4, something else would come along and do that to you.
The fix isn't to get rid of GPT-4. It's to correct whatever underlying emotional and psychological issues are causing the depression.
If toilet rolls keep escalating in supply at the rate ChatGPT has changed from last year, to this year, for ten years straight, then we're all doomed by oversupply of toilet rolls.
Mathematics is a cruel mistress.. when you use it to extrapolate trends over the top of conscious reasoning, simply because you can?