What is baffling to me is the value proposition of second tier colleges which charge pretty much the same tuition as the first tier. Have you heard of Wake Forest University? According to the US News ranking [1], it is ranked at 29 among "National Universities" and charges a tuition of $62k. If you were to see a resume of a candidate graduating from Wake Forest, would you jump on it?
(Note: I don't want to dis Wake Forest U. I just found it on google minutes ago, I don't think I heard about it until now, and I have no idea if it's good or bad. But it certainly does not have the name recognition of Yale, for me, at least)