Yes and thanks for giving me the time of day!
1: Derive that, for a cycle with o odds and e evens, that the product of the increases due to odds (3 + 1/x) must exactly equal the product of the decreases by halving, which comes out to 2^e.
The trivial cycle meets this, since (3+1/1) = 2^2.
As another example, for the alternative rule where odd numbers go up by 3*n + 5, there are some cycles, like 19 => 62 => 31 => 98 => 49 => 152 => 76 => 38 => 19. The increases here come out to approximately 3.26, 3.16, and 3.10, the product of which is exactly 32, or 2^5.
2: Observe that each (3 + 1/x) term (except for trivially small x) is greater than 3, but near it. For x=101, (3+1/x) is about 3.01. As a result, the product of the increases is going to be larger than a product of 3, but somewhat close to one.
3: Observe that we need the little error above the power of 3 to be large enough that the LHS exactly equals a power of 2. This is challenging because as the numbers in the cycle get larger, (3 + 1/x) gets closer to 3.0, which makes it harder for the product to be much larger than a power of 3. And, for large powers of 3, the nearest power of 2 is never particularly close — we actually need this error to compound to a product substantially larger than the power of 3. We can attempt to achieve this with longer cycles for more compounding error, or smaller values of x.
4: Observe that, for a given number of odd numbers in a cycle, we can find an upper bound for the lowest value in the cycle. For example, let’s use o=5. We need (3+1/x1)(3+1/x2)(3+1/x3)(3+1/x4)(3+1/x5) = 2^e. 3^5 is 243, so the easiest e value is 8, making the RHS 256.
If we define x1 as the smallest number in the cycle, we can see that x1 can’t be too large. x1=1001 implies that x2, x3 etc are at least 1003 and 1005 etc. Plugging these in, the LHS is 243.4 — not near 256. And making x2, x3 etc larger only makes it worse.
Okay, so try a smaller x1 - you can compute that the largest possible x1 that can possibly make the LHS equal 256 is 31.
However we know that 31 and every number below it does not have a cycle, so we know there are no cycles of length 5.
We can actually define the RHS as the next power of 2 above 3^o, which is floor(log2(3^o))+1.
5: Repeat this process for larger cycle lengths and you see that the largest viable value does not trend larger, it trends smaller.