Workers should not have to die so Apple can build the iPhone 5
bgr.com
bgr.com
A good read is Factory Girls by Leslie Chang. I went to listen to a talk she gave last year on her experience at Shenzhen. She made a comment that Shenzhen is a very tough place to live. The place is very industrial and polluted. But when she went to the hometown village of one of her friends (a factory worker) for several days during the Chinese New Year, she found herself missing Shenzhen because the conditions of Chinese countrysides were even worse.
This isn't t justify business practices of Apple, Foxconn, or other manufacturers, but it's important to remember that whether an environment is good or bad really depends on what we are benchmarking it with.
On the other hand, just because these little letters of protest can't magically fix the whole Chinese economy doesn't mean they're necessarily useless. Worker rights are not won all at once. They're negotiated a little bit at a time. The more bad PR companies get, the higher the cost of dealing with it, and the easier it becomes for workers to negotiate better working conditions.
Much of Foxconn's response to this dustup will be cosmetic. But cosmetics cost money, too, so some of the response will consist of real reform.
We live in an imperfect world. Everything is somewhat dangerous. People are - literally - dying while making every single product you have ever consumed or seen in the stores. To phrase your argument in absolutes is to reveal yourself as hopelessly naive.
There's a conversation to be had here, but it's probably going to be in the following form: "The fatal accident rate in factories supplying Apple is X per 100,000. I believe it should be Y, and I believe that because of specific reasons A, B, and C." And then we can discuss if X is really too high, and if Y is achievable, and maybe evaluate your reasons, and the likely outcome of trying to bring the rate from X to Y.
But the implication here is that the rate of fatal accidents per year should be zero, and that's ludicrous. Foxconn employs around a million people. How many people do you think have died there in the last year? (Please provide citations to government statistics or independent news articles.)
Meanwhile, the death rate for manufacturing workers in the UK is 1.1 per 100,000; 27 people died in fatal accidents in the UK in the manufacturing sector last year. So...what? "Workers should not have to die so Rolls Royce can build jet engines?" Are these workers being exploited? Should we be boycotting jet engines, air travel, and all products which have travelled by air? Or is, perhaps, a death rate of 1.1 per 100,000 actually an acceptable trade-off?
I think the point is not to single out a particular company, but figure out how to evolve the entire culture so this kind of stuff doesn't happen.
The have similar weak laws like the Working Condition Service act that really do little to force change, but begin to change the mindset of workers. This beginning change of mindset will force real workplace safety regulation in the future, but even in the US it took over 40 years and was mostly because of a side effect from a shipping regulation change that expanded the scope of the DOL to enforce safety requirements on merchant ships. This small change was used as precedence for real regulation in 1970 with OSHA, which was very necessary, with numbers of workplace deaths in the near 15,000.
It will take time for the public will to be great enough to force real change, and it is hard regardless of your buying power to change cultural practices.
Wintek failed to offer these disabled workers adequate monetary compensation and necessary medical aide. And Apple did not monitor Wintek's clean-up act close enough, just took the vendor's word for it. So later 2011 the conflict blew out into a full protest at the factory's gate.
Though Apple is one of Wintek's major clients, the Taiwan based company did not exclusively produce iPhone panels.
The reality is that the construction of any product, even one as aesthetically sleek as the iPhone (or consumer technology in general), is dangerous and doubtlessly comes with human costs. If we're getting upset at this, why not use this to take issue with the production of other consumer products which, doubtlessly, are made just down the road from the iPhone?
So far I have only heard about suicides but they do not seem to be above global averages.
The working conditions could probably be improved but I really don't know since all I read on the topic is sensationalistic.
Surely there are a number of companies that kill far more people that a petition would do more good for.