But this one really takes the cake. My respect for the “academic” field of business has somehow managed to fall below rock-bottom.
But this one really takes the cake. My respect for the “academic” field of business has somehow managed to fall below rock-bottom.
Managerialist culture is founded on the notion that workers must be supervised and controlled. That the important thinking should be done by people in the managerial class. In that context, the experiences of non-managers is always secondary, because workers must be coerced via carrots and sticks to do things they are not smart/wise/good enough to see on their own.
A great example here is the ubiquitous status meeting. Everybody troops into a conference room for an hour and takes turns saying things to the boss while everybody else's eyes glaze over. This lets the boss feel powerful and important, but it's a giant waste of time. The POSIWID conclusion is that organizational effectiveness is very much secondary to reinforcing the dominance hierarchy.
For somebody adapted to that world, treating the time of minions as truly important -- by which I mean more important than the passing feelings of the powerful -- is radical. Even though that's something blatantly obvious to makers and others who do direct work.
That's a shallow view of the situation. What you're describing is "Taylorist" management, or "Theory X" management.
Modern management theory also discusses "Theory Y" management, in which providing context and trust is more important than supervision and control.
Many managers are unaware of this concept, even though it's Management 101. If that's the case in your company, it's not a problem with "managerialist culture"... it's a problem with your company's culture.
Good god, "management" is so deeply devoid of any actual substance that they can't even name their prominent theories? No wonder it's a constant struggle for them to justify their own existence.
Now excuse me while I go work on some C and get a hot cup of Java and complain about JavaScript.
It's possible to have strongly negative opinions of both MBAs and middle managers, even if they don't perfectly overlap.
> now I find it ironic that you find it shocking that managers (who don't complete an MBA) don't know what the prominent theories are
Hard to be "shocked" anymore, since it's so normalized, but if we break it down:
- Management theory is mostly bereft of useful information
- Most managers don't learn the theory anyway
- Most managers don't bother to try to get better at their jobs, and if they do, it's by reading vapid articles like this one or going to the expensive training version of the same
- Higher-level managers earn multiple times what ACs ("actual contributors") earn
- Bad managers can, and do, sink entire teams, and may represent some of the biggest risk to most companies, and yet virtually no effort is ever made to hold any managers accountable for anything, because the only people who could do that are other, higher-level managers, whose jobs are even more worthless, and they know it, so bad managers are kept around because otherwise the entire House of Feudalism could collapse
- Good managers are frequently praised for their ability to protect their reports from the torrent of stupid bullshit coming from above them in the chain, and yet nobody ever asks why the fuck there's a torrent of stupid bullshit coming from higher-level managers, who, again, make much more than the people being protected from their wanton disregard for effective management.
Are you not shocked?
The issue is that anyone unable to intuit what has been said in this HBR rag has no business directing the work of another human being.
No amount of difference in “mindset” or “context” can account for the sheer obviousness or what is being said, nor can it justify passing this off for expert analysis.
To save others a web search.
“The Purpose of a System Is What It Does.”
This is a good point and resonated with me. It would be a better use of the employees time (and thus presumably better for the company) if the boss walks around, and sit down with people to have a chat about the status of the project/status in general. However this would take a lot more time for the boss and probably doesn't feel as empowering as well, so all hands on deck, lets use 1/8 of today to sit and do nothing. I think having a 1 on 1 would help people be more honest about their status, and maybe even the group dynamic in their team as well. I have been a consultant where we were 10+ consultants plus 2-3 internals in a weekly meeting. It baffles me that the customer wanted to do something that costly and ineffective.
But my concern is less about the people writing or publishing this drivel than about the people who consume every drop of it, hoping for some “insight” into “strategic thinking”. Before anyone accuses me of attacking a straw man, I have personally met dozens of such people.
What pains me the most is that there is something out there that can give them what they want; a classic liberal-arts education would actually teach them to think with some rigor. But they’re stuck. They can’t think well enough to dig themselves out of this hole of mediocrity, and it’s an unsettling mix of tragic and repulsive.
So in true HBR form, if you find yourself reading “thought leaders” or looking to improve your “strategic thinking”, please — for all our sakes - read a book. (NYT bestseller doesn’t count.)
but but but, how can you become a thought leader if you don't slurp up this kind of content to regurgitate on your own blog as if it was your original thought and then relentlessly post about it on $theSocials?
If HBR is such a magazine for managerial oriented people then at least it shows that some people are aspiring to improve their ability as managers, or at least the functioning of their organization.
Pretend for a moment you are responsible for the quality of management at a large tech company. You think this article's guidance is obvious but what percentage of managers do you think already practice it? How do you make that number go up?
Also: what makes this article so much worse than http://www.paulgraham.com/makersschedule.html?
What about him? That’s drivel too.
As to your actual point, it’s horrifying that people need to be told “don’t be distracting”, and that this passes for best-in-class analysis on the subject of business organizations.
P.S. as a sibling comment points out, this drivel isn’t even meant to be helpful. It’s meant to be uncontroversial.
What I’m experiencing is closer to despair (and maybe a hint of misanthropy).
If this person were rare, the world wouldn't be nearly as saturated with slogans as it is.
And to be honest, I think we are all this person from time to time, when we are stretched thin.
It's really not best-in-class analysis--that honor probably goes to the Academy of Management Journal[1]. It's a free blog post on a non-peer-reviewed _magazine_'s site. Yes, there is a dynamic that makes paywall journal articles anti-viral, which is why you won't find any at the top of HN.
But I do think the article is meant to be helpful, not just inoffensive. As a manager, your peer and everyone above you is interrupt driven. There is some missed deadline or other crisis you are expected to attend do. Even your employees have an oncall function, and we have all these amazing instant messaging tools like Slack. And agile is all about changing the plan a lot, right? Heck, peopleware has a section on overhead intercoms in the office, to give you an idea of how bad it used to be. And extroverts (ie sales and marketing) don't mind interruptions, maybe even thrive on it if they made a promotion to management. It's just not obvious at all for some section of humanity, unfortunate as it is for us engineers.
Finally, think about it like this: some employers are putting spyware on employee computers to monitor work from home behavior. That is the audience for this article. Not sure why it's on HN.