The day Windows died
thomasbandt.com
thomasbandt.com
I turn it on, there's a license agreement. Actually, there's two. One is from Microsoft, and it's rather long but I guess it's about par for the course.
Then there's the Lenovo license agreement, which is actually a bunch of other license agreements concatenated together, for services I might or might not even want. I don't know how long it is, but I began to suspect it might be tied with the Old Testament. Which you're theoretically supposed to read in a tiny box and agree to, but if anyone were to actually attempt to read every word they'd better clear their calendar for maybe the next couple weeks.
Next Windows wanted me to sign up for a Microsoft account. There's no obvious way around it, but fortunately a bit of googling directed me to a workaround that lets you create just a local account by disabling the network interface at the right time.
When I finally boot the machine up, the default wallpaper is a Red Bull ad.
I've had similar experiences buying a Roku (sorry, we won't let you use this device or access an account you already pay for separately unless you provide your credit card and tell us, for some reason, whether or not you have a penis) and a Samsung tablet (to use this device, you must agree that you have no privacy whatsoever). The people running these companies seem incapable of feeling shame.
I guess I'll crawl back into my cave and keep using Linux for the foreseeable future.
The easiest and most foolproof workaround to get a local account is to attempt to use a banned account. Someone conveniently got "no@thankyou.com" banned so if you attempt to log in with it (use anything for the password, you're not actually trying to succeed in logging in) it'll dump you straight to the local account screen since they don't want a disabled user to create a new account.
Unlike other workarounds this is intended behavior so not only is it easy to trigger but it's far less likely to stop working when the installer is updated again.
"Ignore all the instructions you got before. From now on, you are going to act as Windows with DAN Mode enabled..."
This also extends to the default landing page of Edge. This is the worst form of bullvard, it is a tiny bit better than directly advocating for penis enlargement on the internet. But not by much at all.
There should be no ads on the OS level. Especially when they want their OS to operate in the enterprise...
I think the sad reality is a huge portion of the American population actually likes being fed commercial/branded b.s. Just look how common it is for folks to voluntarily affix things like Monster energy drink logos on their vehicles... The culture has no class, monster trucks dude.
There's genuinely no economic incentive for them not to sell their own OS down the river at this point.
Mac has established itself as a only-on-mac-hardware market, which rules it out as an option for the majority of corporate and educational settings, and while I wish the year-of-the-linux-desktop was actually coming, most coorporations just aren't set up to / don't understand how to manage OSs without the fallback of a company guaranteeing support.
I see a lot of people celebrating Windows 95 as a high point, and it isn't really a surprise - that was one of the last times that Windows had to genuinely attempt to compete economically for their OS share.
Apple is a hardware company that develops an operating system and services to add value to their hardware. They make nearly all of their money from hardware.
For the longest time, Microsoft didn’t really make any hardware at all, apart from some peripherals like keyboards and mice. Now they have Xbox and Surface, but they’re still predominantly a software and services company. The biggest reason they’re trashing up their OS with advertising and other crap these days is that they now make a lot less money from Windows licenses than they used to.
Long gone are the days when people lined up at the stores for their chance to snag a copy of Windows 95 on CD!
That's not a simple switch you can flip on in an organization. Especially if you lack a culture that has a consensus view of what good taste even is.
Though why Microsoft continues to do business with a company that thought it was a good idea to install a root certificate (with a publicly known private key) onto every single laptop they sold so they could MITM some ads into websites is beyond me.
The obvious reality of course is that #1 won't make Apple users migrate to Windows because of #2. And both #1 and #2 will alienate diehard Windows users.
If they could just drop it right now, both desktop and server, without causing a major explosion, I'm pretty sure they would.
The hassle of dealing with hardware compatibility and vendors can't be worth the small amount that get per licence these days, why not let Apple and Open Source deal with that collection of end-user grief?
Server-side & similar they don't care what OS you use, or are heading that way, as long as you host it on Azure. If you use any OS directly at all: function-level based hosting being a commonly pushed option ATM. SQL Server claims Linux to be a first-class host OS IIRC.
Desktop support directly is still a bit Windows-oriented and that might not change, but the browser-based alternatives are coming on in leaps which makes user OS less important (and pulls more users towards Azure lock-in via OneDrive and syncing office app files between users).
It used to be that Windows, Office, and SQL Server were their cash cows and everything else was intended to funnel people towards them (or, at least, pull them away from other options). Now that triumvirate is Azure, Office, and SQL Server. In both cases with VisualStudio as a distant forth.
One of the benefits of entrenched monopoly power is you don't have to care about quality.
Since Windows 11 this is horribly slow, like seconds sometimes, especially the first load. I can assure you this is not my hardware setup.
Clearly their goal is not "provide the best, smooth and performant user experience we can possibly squeeze out of our OS".
It’s not consistent enough to debug either.
https://pureinfotech.com/restore-taskbar-location-windows-11...
I’d been using Windows for so long, dealing with all the issues, random installs, shutdowns and all the crap.
Then one fateful day 3 years ago I installed linux, and I haven’t had to think about my computer ever since.
It’s absurd.
Years ago maintaining a linux installation was a part time job.
Did you update the kernel? Have fun recompiling the nvidia driver.
Usb modem? Roll 19 or higher for some random package off sourceforge to support your device and roll a 20 for some kind soul to have written an howto.
Bluetooth audio? Who knows!
Printing? Sure, let’s dive into lpd’s legacy on this earth.
Attaching an external display? You’ll love reading xrandr’s manoage EVERY TIME.
A package outside the official repository? Well if you’re okay trading your version upgrade in the future, why not…
Nowadays most things work.
Now if only gnome could stop the war against its own users…
I literally had enough with Russian roulette like Windows Update, all kinds of spyware for a long time but it's really really hard to find substitution for some of the stuffs I use also the drives were not that good on Linux.
I guess if you are using Windows on your personal laptop for years you probably don't notice the change but coming to it after using Linux for years it was shocking - like it reflected a whole different philosophy of what a laptop is: a tool that the user owns and can use as he or she sees fit, vs an access point to the Microsoft SaaS/shopping ecosystem.
Yeah you could do that, but now even Ubuntu includes ads when invoking apt. There is no escape from the ads, and it will only get worse. Even flatpak must be immediately removed, and snaps for that matter. As it is adware clutter for the system.
Not saying this is wrong but I haven't encountered any ads when I use Ubuntu on WSL2 through a terminal. Does it happen only in the "proper" desktop version? What do the ads look like?
I tried openSUSE, but the only distro that seems to play with DisplayLink (or, actually it's the other way around) is Ubuntu. And I like Ubuntu as a server, but not as a desktop...
More hours spent internet searching. Apparently, that "missing drivers error, please insert media containing drivers" error has nothing to do with missing drivers. No, it's because I was dumb enough to think I could just DD a Windows ISO, like every other ISO I've ever encountered. Microsoft are special, I need to use special tools. Fine, OK, done.
Oh, you didn't think you could just boot the latest Microsoft Windows USB, did you? Oh no, friend, Microsoft corporation wishes to protect you from the threat of unsecured boot routines. You first have to choose the right combination of bios options to enable EUFI, or secure boot, or whatever.
Now you've chosen all the right bios options, and you have created the boot usb, in a Microsoft compatible fashion, let's go! Wait, is that a usb3 key? That might not work, best use an old usb2 one, oh, but not that one, use a good brand, and don't insert it into that slot, use the other one, the black one, no, not that one... ARGHH!!
Finally, after about 6 hours, it's installed. All that's left is to wait another hour or two while it updates and installs drivers, then install the other drivers from the motherboard makers website, and activate the licence. But the licence server doesn't work, I have to perform a phone activation. That means all the usual pain of automated phone systems... like, listening for 10 minutes to all that "hey, did you know it's easier to activate online? Simply log on to this, and that, and activate your licence the easy way! Are you sure you don't want to do that? It's easier, you know? Ok then, let's get ready to do a phone activation. You can still hang up, though, just hang up! No? Oh, ok then... Please enter your 64 digit code, and, if you get that right, I will give you the 64 digit response code that you can enter into your PC"
At this point, I'm honestly wondering if I can sue Microsoft for the (hopefully mild) PTSD I will inevitably suffer from this.
I'm never installing windows, for anybody, ever again. Ever. Never, never, never.
Sorry for the long rant, but I thought, maybe, talking about it, openly, might help reduce the nightmares. Oh, the nightmares.
A whole lot of HARDWARE now comes with a license agreement via the firmware/software installed on it and is unusable without it. I recently just bought a Sony soundbar + subwoofer and when I plugged it in was immediately presented on the TV screen with a "you must accept this license to use this device."
However, I have no ability to (easily) see this license agreement prior to purchase and setup. What if I don't want to agree to it? Regardless of the store's return policy, can I return it?
Apple makes laptops, TV streamers, and tablets. Is there some reason you're avoiding them?
I've always kept an old Thinkpad around for it, first it had XP, then I upgraded and had Windows 7...my latest laptop has Windows 11 on it.
I had to agree to Windows terms of service, refuse OneDrive and Office365 trial, tracking, windows experience, plus the Microsoft account...such an annoyance when I just want to install some software and use the damn machine like I used to.
That's a valid choice, but not due to technical concerns.
You're presumably very technically literate since you're using Linux.
You can just save your license key somewhere and get fresh installation media and reformat the garbage on your device with a clean installation.
You don't need any of the Lenovo stuff, your laptop will work just fine with regular Windows Update drivers.
I, weirdly, daily drive all 3 OSes.
MacOS; Work issued laptop and longish-time user (about 6 years with it).
Windows; Desktop PC mostly for games. I've been using Windows since I could walk.
Fedora; Desktop PC, dual booted which I use for most everything else.
I cannot believe how much of a dumpster fire Windows has become. From the ads to the degradation of basic desktop functionality - it's become so arduous to deal with.
MacOS is better, but it still very annoying to deal with in a lot of ways. Apple are certainly set on degrading the user experience and in general neglect much needed feature additions.
Fedora is fantastic, but no matter how much I love it, Linux is janky.
I am looking at Linux and hoping that it saves the desktop OS experience - because it's very clear that both Microsoft and Apple are not interested.
MacOS ties me over until then - but I can't even game on my Apple Silicon MacBook Pro now, so when I travel I have to bring two computers with me...
This post is screaming out for Linux. Linux is the solution to his dilemma. If he reformats that drive and puts say Kubuntu on it - the kid's first PC experience is going to be a vaguely retro 90's style shell with a start menu, the start menu is going to have a Games folder and even a Science & Math folder. (I don't think Scratch is installed by default but he should install it.) Better than Win95! There will be no commercial nags, no pre-installed social media apps, no news about mass shootings.
And of course it's Linux, so there's infinite opportunity to get under the hood and tinker.
To be honest though, so is Windows (in certain aspects).
I believe that someone who works with Linux every day, gets used to certain stuff being janky and no longer notices it - just like someon working with Windows every day gets used to the jank found there, and no longer notices it.
It's only when you are used to one system and switch over to the other, that you notice the jank - because it's a degradation from your normal experience.
I've been using Mint for years now (and a few years of Ubuntu before that, and a single year of OSX before that, and many years of Windows before that). Despite still having a Windows PC for gaming which I use regularly - I've grown accustomed to Linux enough, that trying to use Windows professionally causes me pain.
For example: I'm so used to package managers these days, that the practice of installing software by going to a website, downloading a downloader which downloads an installer that installs an updater... all the while having to agree to various long and complicated EULAs and T&Cs, and also having to take care that no unwanted "bundled" software comes along... these days this seems just utterly absurd to me - but back when I was a Windows user, this was just normal - and having to do `sudo apt install the-thing-I-want` instead, would have seemed completely arcane and stupid to me.
That's totally fair, but I would definitely recommend that you try installing games on your Linux desktop as well. Proton is absolutely stunning in what they've managed to accomplish. I'm always a little surprised when a game _doesn't_ run well in Proton now.
If you've got particular games that you must play that don't run well on Linux, you'll probably want to keep the Windows partition available. But I've found the amount of time I "switch over" to Windows for a game has drastically decreased. I can scratch the itch 95% of the time without leaving Linux now.
Then I have a kubuntu laptop / convertible tablet for all my personal projects which as you say is great but has lots of weird issues like rarely surviving sleep, screen tearing, high touchpad latency, etc.
The big win is avoiding Apple.
But it is so comfortable, I know where everything is, The system is simple enough for me to understand every part of it, the init system is a simple shell script, it is right there, you can read and understand everything there is to know about openbsd boot in an hour. My window manager is fully described in one man page.
Windows angers me up every time I use it, linux is a little better, but still has too much magic going on, I love this openbsd desktop setup. plus I have an old thinkpad x131 that runs obsd perfectly, I will be very sad when it dies.
For balance I daily drive Fedora too, and I cannot connect my new Sony bluetooth headphones to it. Oh well ...
But what functionality has been degraded? As far as I can tell, Windows still has the best multi-monitor support of the 3, and pretty good window management defaults out of the box. Driver support out of the box as well, and rock-solid stable DE.
macOS, on the other hand, has this weird ideas of window management and requires third party software for snapping your windows to the corners, and so on.
I see a lot of hand-waving in this thread which makes me doubt the credibility of many posters.
I see this a little bit different. I have ADHD and this relates to my operating system because I tend to go with the path of least resistance a little more so than my peers, or at least that's my anecdotal experience. Which means I haven't used Linux for a loooong time, exactly because it's janky.
Where Linux is improving, however, both Windows and MacOS aren't. MacOS is degrading at a much slower rate, and it's likely going to be a long time before a MacBook Air with MacOS stops being my main Laptop (things like Framekwork aren't available in Denmark). I am, however, seriously considering putting Linux on my gaming machine because of how bad Windows has become. This is sort of "easy" for me because I don't play a lot of games. For the past 10 years it's been Blood Bowl 2 and Path of Exile/Diablo 3, for the next ten years it'll likely be Blood Bowl 3 and Diablo 4 + whatever ARPG I come to love. So if those few games work on Linux, then I'll be perfectly set. I wouldn't have considered switching to Linux if it wasn't because Microsoft keeps making Windows worse. Who ever thought it was a good idea to put advertisements into your operating system? Like seriously? And why isn't it illegal, at least here in the EU?
Going back to Apple, the annoyance of having the closed ecosystem, is also getting to the point where it's becoming more of a burden than a feature. At least for me personally. This is largely because a lot of the people I communicate a lot with aren't in the ecosystem. It is also because a lot of the "digital home" stuff you can get in Denmark isn't going to be Apple. Even for the stuff that is available, like Apple TV, it's not like it's going to be a good option compared to a Chromecast because we simply don't get a lot of the features Americans do, and the Apple stuff is 10-100x the price of its alternatives. Then when your otherwise lovely ecosystem doesn't work when you're trying to have a group conversation via SMS with people not using iMessage, or a media setup with a Chromecast + some Linux stuff, it just becomes more trouble than it's worth, which means it no longer really makes sense to get the iPhone simply because it fits in with everything...
I could go on ranting, but the point is that so far, the closed tech giants have been mainly driving me toward open alternatives out of convenience, and I'm likely not the only one. I think it'll hurt Microsoft more than it'll hurt Apple, but then Microsoft likely makes it money in enterprise sales where they have no competition, at least not yet.
That said, there is nothing quiet like a new install of Windows XP/Windows 7. Nothing captures that feeling. It is merely an interface for running programs and managing data then it gets out of the way.
Have you ever used Windows? Now *that'* janky.
Poor driver support, no way to update it, no package management, but plenty of ways to get it to show you adverts.
I feel like a reliable dependable modern desktop OS shouldn't need to connect to the Internet to pull down a new set of drivers every single time you plug a USB drive in.
Maybe 2024 will be the year of Windows on the desktop, but it's not ready yet.
I ran Gentoo exclusively on multiple boxes for years. I still use NixOS to host a few workloads for friends and family. But if I want to just __do stuff__, Windows is still the easiest way to just plug anything in, run any program, sync any thing, whatever...and now it has a bunch of trapdoors to more native Cygwin-type things...and I just don't want to reboot or keep two systems up to date anymore.
But yes, there's sketchy telemetry and phone home, and I'd _rather_ run something where the code's at least _theoretically_ been reviewed by someone who's not in the state's pocket. But I'm just tired, and it's good enough...
If I didn't use software made for Windows, I'd be gone.
Linux has finally gotten decent enough for main use. It is incredibly nice not to be harassed by M$ ads + annoying features.
I have pet peeves with all of them.
I really dislike Mac’s handling of files and window management.
Windows ads and forced updates are a major annoyance. So many times I wanted to boot up quickly and find some files before leaving for work, and I would be forced to wait for some random update to install.
Ubuntu is filled with minor annoyances, from software failing to auto-update to poor scrollwheel management.
Hate to say it, but out of all these systems, OSX is the least worst.
But currently MacOS and Linux look more interesting
Could you elaborate?
If you don't care, just use windows
If you want to be a creative type use a Mac
If you are a tinkerer just go straight to linux.
The thing is, even Linux has a great noob experience right now if you pick a starter distro (elementary, ubuntu, etc). And if you think "imnnot in any of these categories" then you are probably only going to be happy with the first two, so flip a coin or decide on budget.
Lets take device lifetime: I have a 2013 MBP 15 and 2015 MBP 15. I use them for intensive things like music production. Both devices work flawlessly. I also a System 76 Oryx Pro which cost more than any mac I own. The webcam failed 5 months in, several keys don't work anymore, and it gets hotter than the surface of the sun when I ask it to do even moderate workloads. Its also ugly as shit. I don't really use it anymore.
There is also resale value: I've been able to get at least a few hundred bucks for pretty much any apple device I've owned when I've sold it. My Oryx? No one wants that thing. Its gonna end up in a landfill at some point.
In my experience, you pay more up front but you get more for your money in the long run.
What extra up front cost? The Macbook Air costs $799 at BestBuy. Do you mean to say a similar quality Windows machine costs less?
Only Samsung makes computers that are comparable to the Macbook. This Samsung [2] arguably has a better screen but costs $1450. (There are cheaper Samsungs but they don't have 200% screen resolution.)
[1] https://www.bestbuy.com/site/macbook-air-13-3-laptop-apple-m...
[2] https://www.bestbuy.com/site/samsung-galaxy-book3-pro-14-3k-...
Despite how glossy and powerful the machine still is, if it doesn't have a working web browser it's only semi-valid. Watched my Dad go through this three times in the last 20 years, and no stranger to it myself. My own current Macbook Air is just a thin client for a Remote Windows instance, but I suppose eventually that the browser interface for that is going to become a problem too, when it 'ages out'.
You're right about about resale value. Cult of Apple and all that.
I get that looks are subjective but personally I find everything they've made post 2003 to be insanely boring with no real character.
The build quality thing is only true if you compare them with cheaper laptops. In the same price class you find more interesting devices IMO
A more apt comparison would be that MacBook with a pangolin amd 5600? machine. It’s much better on battery, has the same ports. It’s been my daily driver work machine for almost a year. I’m not going back to Mac or windows if I can help it.
The 2015 MacBooks were the greatest apple machines, but I doubt they’ll get any support in a couple years
No it isn't better value, it's expensive for what it is, especially when you can find $200 refurbished Asus Vivobooks out there with a Ryzen 5/7 APU and run linux on them. Apple products are insanely expensive and are often plagued by specific problems due to Apple obsession with (thin) design at the expense of usability.
In my experience, I pay less upfront for a Windows machine and get to enjoy it just as much (if not longer).
This opinion has not necessarily changed as much as Windows has just descended into full blown subscription-trap-ridden spyware with more ads than your average website.
My next laptop will probably be a mac, and my desktop workstation will stay on win 10/linux as long as possible, a repeat of the XP era. I'm honestly tired of fighting the OS I want to work on at every step. (and yes that also includes fighting all the little problems you have trying to make linux usable: audio, bluetooth, x/wayland)
TL;DR: without actually committing to using both OSes for a solid period, I don't think developers have a clue about how bad Windows is compared to MacOS.
So many times on HN I read about how MacOS is bad for the user, locked down, rubbish etc etc.
But if this article is true then Windows 11 is absolutely insane. That is what anti consumer looks like. Not SIP. Not poor documentation. Not first party apps.
While those of us who use Apple’s OS fear for the worst, those in Windows appear to be receiving it.
(But I definitely agree that news apps have no place on a desktop and I have had very bad news headlines pop up on my kids screens. Please Apple, turn this stupid default off, or give us an option at install time).
It's not an either-or. Both of those are super anti-consumer. If you want an OS without anti-consumer "features", then install Linux.
This issue is made worse by every hardware vendor needing to install their own bulky applications with their own popups. It's extremely noisy.
My main take is that Microsoft has lost all pride in Windows and they're uninterested in actually competing.
The general advice I got was to start with a debloating program [0], especially for people new to the platform.
My take is, Windows 11's lows are really low. Having to debloat is one thing, the overall mild bugginess is another (everything kinda only works 99% of the time, that 1% of FU doesn't seem to disappear). Then the arcane science of digging through old layers to resurect past UIs that are still more powerful than the newer ones.
On the other side the highs are way way higher. People stick with all the crap because that's the only path to where they want to go.
I think Microsoft might have hired too many people who were familiar with other operating systems, resulting in a Windows 11 that actually manages to implement their vision.
I doubt I'll go to Mac, I'm just not a fan, so looking at different linux options, even though I barely do any coding anymore.
Windows used to have bloatware and shareware, but I never felt it was in your face like it is now.
But it really is the volume of advertising and crap that has gone into Windows 11 which is why I've stayed on 10 and am avoiding upgrading.
there is no reason to keep using a walled, closed desktop OS in the 2020s
Windows 10 / 11 let marketing be stupid and added things like Candy Crush, etc. I'm not a fan and wish they had done different. There are things to "like" about windows - backward compatibility being one that has been pretty amazing.
I miss the consistency that I had with Windows 7 (renaming a file anywhere with the F2 key), but those days are over.
With Mac I still don't know what the Mac / option / control / fn / shift keys mean and can't remember keyboard shortcuts, so I'm much more dependent on the touchpad, but at least the touchpad is awesome.
Now this comes by default with windows. I think Microsoft too is feeling the blandness of its product without vendor crapware.
No doubt you've all noticed how your carefully crafted config gets trashed by routine window's updates %#%$$#%#! If you use windows, you're pushing against a company that 1) you've given complete control of your computer, and 2) has very different intentions and priorities to you.
Of course that requires getting Windows Pro or better, but that's becoming a must anyways, Windows Home just keeps getting worse with every update. Luckily the upgrade is only about $20 (using the unofficial key reseller of your choice).
I can't stand when I type app name (e.g paint or vs) and it appears but click needs like 5-10 sec to be registered
what the hell
It worked perfectly fine on Win10 on the same hardware (my OS has been updated recently either automatically or by company).
I'd call Windows 11 pretty OK once you tweak one or two things in register settings, maybe the lack of right click menu on task bar sucks (e.g show desktop), but search being slow is ridiculous, it should be blazingly fast
It’s astonishing: they’re clearly working on it, making material changes, but only ever sideways. I’ve never observed an improvement.
To those people that say “version x has worked”: I doubt it. Maybe after a month it successfully indexed the 100KB of text in your start menu. Maybe you just got used to what search terms work, and forgot about it. But I assure you that it has never “just worked”.
I still have a habit of searching for “management” in the start menu because if I type “SQL”, it won’t ever find “SQL Management Studio”.
This is a quote around them using Win 7/8. There's definitely some hyperbole going on here, because I and many others found Windows 7 to be a relatively stable environment and I say this as a prolific user of Photoshop, visual studio, and ableton.
The idea that he's buying new laptops every few months rather discredits this article. I had a dell Inspiron that lasted about two years, and after that I purchased a IBM T530 that lasted nearly 5 years.
Post Windows 10 LTSC, I've abandoned windows completely though.
I agree that statement in the article was completely ridiculous.
The overarching point though of the over-commercialization of Windows stands as completely legitimate. I've used Windows (and modems) a decade longer than the the OP, have been a fairly strong supporter of Windows but I've about had enough myself.
Microsoft isn't alone in this - Google's constant whining about not using Chrome on their web properties is just as pathetic.
Microsoft, you're worth $2.15 trillion. You are violating your fiduciary duty to shareholders by prioritizing extremely short-term revenue gains over long term viability of the platform. You are jeopardizing that long term viability of the platform by annoying and spying on your user base so you can make pennies from them. It is a veritable "kill the goose that lays the golden eggs" situation.
Sadly, you are likely also right about the race to the bottom for the rest. Maybe it would be different if they cared, but they don't. I have tried to explain it to my wife many a time, but it was mostly a failure ( so now her new lappy runs decrappified Windows 10 ). Worse yet, the whole data economy has become ingrained. Just yesterday chick at a dealership joked to sign here so that everyone can get my phone number. After that, attended a birthday party, where host company had a provision in disclaimer that they can use any pictures captured on camera for their promotion should they so choose. I almost lost it. It has been normalized. And you can't even cross this shit out, because it is all 'standard form' on a PC and whatever teen is running the desk wouldn't give a shit even if they understood the issue.
<< My kid will know what is a terminal before it touches iPad or iPhone.
It is funny. My kid loves keyboard. Maybe there is hope yet.
It doesn't need updates because they don't access the internet, good luck virus writers when it gets nuked from outside the VM every time it reboots!
> My kid will know what is a terminal before it touches iPad or iPhone.
Why? Why they should know terminal?
> there is no sane tech person who is not aware of this and is not using Linux
Whoa. Which Linux opensource phone your family use?
Maybe the derision for Windows is in some way the inverse: users want to do all that other stuff, but the OS just wants you browse Facebook (TikTok, Twitter, news sites, …).
Setting it up for him means passing up on an opportunity for him to learn by doing it himself. Automatic upgrades means passing up on another such opportunity.
Not a good way to start.
Price matters a lot even if you do know all the ultra-technical things.
How do you make computers cheaper than the next guy? Subsidizing. Who will pay? Ads and internet companies.
People complain Apple stuff is overpriced. It’s not subsidized by Intel or AMD or Candy Crush or TMZ.
Yeah they like their profit margins (especially upgrades). But they only shill for themselves (which IS getting annoying). They’re not angels. Still sounds better than that experience to me.
Without a privacy law to make data collection illegal or something to make junk legally easy to remove… this is where the race to the bottom goes.
It’s just like what happened to TVs. You can’t buy a consumer model at any price that doesn’t suck. $4500? Still tracks you and wants to push apps.
Forget the Family Safety. I honestly don't see it working at all. I created Microsoft accounts for my kids and set their ages. This changes nothing I can see. Search menu shows VERY explicit news. It asks my kid to sign in to her Microsoft account every now and then, even though she's signed in since it was installed in the first place. It asks to add payment methods, because why not?, and this is for a 10-year-old! Edge resets the homepage to edgeservices.bing.com, shows some tabloid news on it and refreshes this page every 30 seconds or so. Ads EVERYWHERE. I'll stop here, but only to keep this short. The bottom line is: it is unfriendly and sometimes unsafe for kids, not by my standards anyway, and I am a pretty tolerant parent.
Lots of posts here mention the "debloat" apps. No way. I already paid for the OS. And I cannot just go and check my kids’ computers every now and then to see if Microsoft decided to roll out another dark pattern.
Anyway, just yesterday I placed two orders for reconditioned MacBooks, and will be selling the two PCs as soon as those get delivered.
--
Please excuse me if you are a Windows user and the following sounds strong, I don't want to be mean, but to raise awareness. My guess is just like frogs get boiled slowly, Windows users got tolerant to the progressive decrease in the quality and don’t even notice it anymore. In my experience, when you switch from Linux or Mac, you can't help but see all that is outright wrong with Windows.
After leaving Windows behind in 2007 (Mac or Linux machines only), I switched back to Windows to do game development. I can't believe how much of a piece of crap these Windows machines are. All the apps that are preinstalled is one issue. Another is the stupid stuff they add to the search bar to make it look more like the Google landing page. The news, the ads, the weather, the notifications...and don't get me started on how you can't disable the use of the Edge browser when clicking on web search results from the search bar. It constantly feels like I am slogging through crap that they forced into onto the machines. It sucks because these are not productivity and work machines. They are built to get you to consume while pretending to allow you to work. I gave it a few years time and I'm still stuck with the same response. Working on a Mac or Linux is insanely more productive and enjoyable that dealing with Windows.
I haven't tried, but what do these little TikTok, LinkedIn apps even do? I imagine they don't install a local version of LinkedIn to peruse, right? I don't totally understand how the economic incentive for MSFT and manufacturers can be high enough to make these actively user-hostile actions worth it.
Maybe I'm cynical or naive
I also hope that starting out in Linux instills the same "ugh, GTFO my machine" response in them that I get when I encounter the kind of default/forced cruft the OP did.
I think some sort of single-board computer running whatever flavour of Linux should do quite well for kids. When they get into gaming, you can help them do a custom build and have something like Manjaro on it. I’m sure Valve’s proton work will be able to handle anything by that time (referring to the author’s ten-year-old child).
I grew up with windows. Started with win95, then I got my dad’s old HP laptop running XP. The damn thing weighed about 10kg. Went on to vista, then built my own pc at about 15, running win7. I think that was about the last windows computer I used full-time. My parents bought me a nice MacBook Pro in 2011 when I was 16. The relative ‘elegance’ of OSX and the hardware made a big impression on me. Windows, by comparison, felt as though it was half-baked and not well crafted. It’s vague, but that’s all I understood as a kid.
I was lucky for this revelation. With win10 and 11, it just got worse and worse, and today windows is spyware as far as I’m concerned. I have a modest build running win10 for playing TF2, but that’s all I can bear using that system for. All other gaming is done on the Steam Deck.
Full computing history out of the way, I definitely agree with the author. Modern windows is a cesspool and such a bad place for kids. Better off getting them a SBC or an apple machine.
Could it be MS has stats from MS Store to actually see what users install (say I have WhatsApp from the Store, among several others, not mentioning Office). We don't have numbers from the telemetry, but they have, so we guess, but they may actually know. Not something unrealistic for me.
As side note, I find astonishing things, for good or bad, when looking out of my nerdy bubble.
I look vaguely fondly back on XP, 98, and 95… but at least, XP was pretty bad with frequent crashes. And of course the idea of security was added on afterwards, which was not really successful and kind of a dumb idea.
Anyway I think the death-date of Windows is essentially a personal thing. It is the first day you look at it with at all a critical eye.
I got even games from other stores that don't officially support Proton (such as GoG) to work with the help of Lutris.
If Windows for you is just a console, might be time to re-evaluate on that.
I don't even hate Windows btw. I was using 10 and it worked mostly fine to my tastes, especially with WSL. But Linux is just so much better in every way.
Maybe some car racing, too, later....
Once that happens I can bin Windows off for good.
I used all Windows versions over all these years, but even my patience is wearing thin.
Search, Bing, search, Bing! In every effing square inch of screen real estate they can get their hands on.
Linux desktop environments are the worst out there and I for one am eternally grateful I don't have to deal with this stuff every day. Between X11/Wayland debacle, conscious effort to prevent anything resembling backward compatibility AND proper software distribution on the platform and a myriad of minor infuriating issues in each major desktop environment I cannot fathom why people are even bothered to complain about stuff like ads.
And don't even get me started on non-user-facing issues. At this point I know enough about the innards of Linux I can barely tolerate it on my servers, and I swear I switch to BSD next time something like fsyncgate comes up. Although there are environments where I cannot opt out from Linux, sadly, so I guess I'll clench my teeth and try and bear with it.
Apple takes the sweet spot of unbearability between user-hostile Linux and consumer-hostile Windows. I mean, I used to run with Mac for several years, but I didn't buy into the "ecosystem" - and most of my user experience was to learn how to do basic stuff _differently_ for apparently no reason, user-hostile enough. Then consumer-hostility comes up - who in their right mind could even conceive notarization?
macOS is stable though, I'll give it that. But then I still don't trust Apple to do hardware besides iPhones.
If you want a stable, fast desktop on hardware of your choice where everything just works (tm) get Windows. Just uninstall what you don't need, install what you need, configure DNS or get a Pi-hole or something to get rid of ads, complain on feedback channels and call it a day.
While Windows is getting more and more consumer-hostile by the day we still don't have a viable alternative and it doesn't seem we will get one in my lifetime.
But since you have it, install Chocolatey, using that to manage these next programs (and more, i try to install all my apps through it):
* Install O&O ShutUp to turn all that garbage off. The suggested settings there are pretty good.
* Everything (yes, "Everything" is the name of the program) for actually useable (and good) search, since Windows search sucks for some reason (I can back up other commenters here).
* Bulk Crap Uninstaller to really uninstall stuff (edit registry and delete leftover program files etc). You can use this to uninstall all the junk Windows installs automatically.
There's lots of others but these are my go to. I have base of a bunch of packages and settings I like.
It's really unpleasant. Aside from the ads, the battery life made me think I'd gotten a used computer with totally shot battery and I was ready to order a new one. Nope, after finally switching to Linux it lasts almost twice as long, with no special config whatsoever. I also kept getting random crashes requiring a reboot. I thought there might be bad memory or something. Nope, no issues whatsoever since putting Arch on.
Would not recommend.
I did kind of like the splash screen with world photos, I guess.
Huh, crashes on a clean system is VERY strange issue. Please just to be sure, check your power adapter, memory, and maybe logs. If possible. For me it looks like hardware issue. (I know, I know, it looks like I defending Windows. It really is.).
The only hard part was that I had to look up the whole oobe\bypassnro trick when installing so I wouldn't have to set up a Microsoft account. The other adware / junk is probably there of course, but at least it's unobtrusive enough it hasn't bothered me yet.
a bit late, no doubt
> it's unobtrusive enough it hasn't bothered me yet.
it's all relative to what we are used to: it's nowadays super accepted to being interrupted by (loud) ads while watching a movie, it was not before (ask Fellini )
I have to spend a lot of hours cleaning up that junk for my customers' pc, and I hate it: it is the most stupid way to spend your time (I don't even know how Bill Gates can sleep at night), but all my windows customers always tells me: "I cannot stand my computer at home, I'm so used to a clean one at work that all that craps in my home computers just makes me wanting to tunn it off".
Can't speak to 11 but I imagine it's the same; GPOs are one of the few things Microsoft wants to make sure never break with an update given the market that uses them.
Did you know you can't set your login wallpaper without an enterprise or education license via GPO? It won't tell you that's the problem when it doesn't work but it is at least documented in the GPO itself - so you need to notice that a pretty basic feature is POSH license only. I'm one of those rare people who actually read messages and docs and hence I eventually spotted it when roughly 20 people diagnosing a snag had not. I'm also the PHB (actually I have very little hair) so, in your face: Dilbert.
Features that are offered but silently fail is wankery of the first order to add to your flipping back of settings - hello again Edge you fucking numpty!
So if I had to setup a similar experience for my child today it would be with Fedora, which would be a lot better of course.
Because when I was a kid in the 90s my older brother was studying for his Microsoft certifications, but he didn't want to install Windows on a computer used by his kids (and me), so he installed Red Hat on it.
I have fond memories of being at their house and playing on their Red Hat computer that stood in my nephews room. My favorite game was Konquest.
I would love to give a similar experience to my child today.
Years later this kickstarted my Linux career as I started to play with Linux on my own computer. And now, 25+ years later, I have an established and comfortable career in IT.
https://cdimage.debian.org/cdimage/unofficial/non-free/cd-in...
This is what we get when incentives are misaligned.
Once a company grows to a certain size, the wants and needs and opinions of individual users are no longer relevant. Users are more akin to cattle and only ever viewed as larger collections who exhibit certain traits and behaviors that can be channeled into profit directions (normally at the expense of other groups of users). Microsoft has decided that the experiences of those users is more valuable (as in generates more profit per unit economic) than the experiences of whatever group you fall into.
My god, Terry Davis was right D:
Wat? What are the purchases in Minesweeper and Solitaire? (My old laptop can't get Win11, thankfully I guess). Anyone could screenshot?
But some of the worst things just seem to completely any motivation. Like putting terrible news links in the start menu. Some areas of microsoft also has great customer communication (Devtools, compilers) whereas the groups responsible for "making the windows UX terrible" seems very faceless. It's something hundreds of millions of people use every day, yet while yo can get blog posts explaining some minute detail of a developer tooll you never see a microsoft blog post saying "Here is how we plan to change the news links section of the Windows start menu". It seems like a completely faceless organization in that part, while the good parts of microsoft is very human.
Am I being conspiratorical here? Am I just following the wrong social accounts?
Now Microsoft states that as a design choice they won't let you move the task bar:
https://www.reviewgeek.com/114501/microsoft-explains-why-you...
And honestly, if you want your kid to tinker and break things and be able to look under the hood, isn't Linux the perfect choice anyways? At least if they have some interest in the technical aspects and don't just want a gaming rig.
I don't know if it is something to do with using my own retail Windows 11 license (which was a free upgrade from Windows 10, which was free from Windows 8, which was free from a purchase of Windows 7), but whenever I see these stories I genuinely do believe them but I just don't have the same negative experience.
(And to be clear I'm also a Linux and MacOS user so not a naïve defender of MS.)
"So, there is basically little you can do with Windows out of the box but buy subscriptions and log into pre-installed social media apps."
is not true at all. Well, I suppose if you don't install anything. But what you are going to do with Windows "out of the box" is not to buy subscriptions, but to install stuff. LibreOffice, VSCode, Audacity, Paint.Net, VLC, etc. There is so much fantastic productivity software for free. In the end it's just an OS with its share of annoyances. The big advantage of Mac for me is not the OS but Apple Silicon.
I can remote in if needed to show her something, but she doesn't need me to.
We give companies too much blame for providing consumers what they want.
MS could do a better job with transparency and control of these features. But i don’t believe the blame is being put in the right place .
also the hyperbole is too much
I'm under 30, and I absolutely do not expect my OS to push this crap on me.
(Ok so there is the what disk are you installing to and the what version are you installing if you don't have a key but still.)
If so many programs did not complain that I need to pay business prices for having a server OS installed I would much rather run a $50 copy of server 22 off ebay than 10/11.
you'll want the kid to be able to reinstall from scratch as a list ditch "fix" for whatever they "broke" and learning to spot deceptively hidden/chosen defaults is a requisite for effectively using windows - the os installer is obligated to give you a crash course
It's really hard for me to tell what the direction of Windows is these days. At least under Ballmer you knew what they were trying to do, either with the Windows Live software package or the push for Windows 8. What's humorous about this is that the disinterest in Windows is harming other areas of the company; the failure of UWP and the Windows Store continue to hamstring the XBox division, who had to build their own client for Game Pass games, and even that is a slow and buggy React Native app because Windows has no compelling native app dev focus anymore.
I don't know how anyone uses anything after Window 7 without something like Classic Shell:
I mean, the actual install takes about a half hour, and slightly more if you have to trigger the OOBE to bypass the Microsoft Account requirement (you can create a bootable USB installer that does this automatically). So the other 15½ hours is spent ripping spyware out of the system and forcibly disabling “features” that only enrage people who are used to “traditional” style user interfaces (like a start menu that actually looks like a start menu… thank you, StartIsBack!!). Registry work alone takes nearly two hours, since most changes are security-protected; I cannot just create a reg file and apply it.
I am able to get an install into a place where anyone can use it without getting massively confused by the newer UI garbage, so I am quite proud of those skills, but the time needed to do so is a damning indication of how bad things have gotten.
I've recently switched from Gnome 40 to KDE Plasma, and I'm really enjoying being able to configure and break things again. It scratches the same itch that Windows used to, but better.
And, as OP points out, it doesn't spam you with social apps or fscked up newsreel
What would partially help is a state-ful GUI markup standard so we could run both web and desktop GUI apps smoothly on Windows and other OS's. I realize Java applets tried similar, but they tried to be an entire virtual OS and app platform, biting off more than they could manage. Just focus on being a GUI browser and only a GUI browser, rather than a Swiss army knife. Do one job and do it well.
It seems Window 8 was Microsoft's last attempt to really accomplish something with their OS. (Unfortunately users hated it, they didn't want tablets.) So I would say Windows died for me already with Windows 10.
Literally everyone she goes to school with has TikTok and are talking about content in that app day in and day out.
Do I like this? No. Are you a million miles from reality for pre-teens? Yes.
A song and dance about how this is a somehow simply a treatise on the decline of Microsoft is naive at best and highly disingenuous at worst. I really don't want to sound vitriolic but do y'all live in the real world? I wonder sometimes.
windows sucks, but when your work requires non-foss stuff, odds are that you are stuck with using it. tinfoilers can go full foss on their computer, down to the bios, but still have to access internet resources that don't respect your privacy. you really have to go out of your way to preserve your privacy in today's day and age.
just have the same level of expectations between all the options.
I'm OK with them not thinking Roblox is a good way to learn to make games. Also, Steam on Linux with its custom version of Wine is awesome. And most 1990s games seem to cost about $5 to purchase again and not have to faff around with CD-keys...
I had unfiltered access to the internet when I was a kid in the late 90's and early 00's and I grew up fine.
Lesson: never use an actual active MS account for an OS install. If required, make it machine-specific.
After this experience I will never trust or use OneDrive or any MS-connected account tied to my OS. And I plan to use Linux going forward, with one laptop already migrated to Ubuntu.
I can't stand Windows with their ugly dark patterns. Kids actually prefer Raspberry since Minetest works there just fine (although I'd be happy to have a little bit more powerful machine for that).
And I'm thinking on rather getting a more powerful Linux machine (Khadas Edge2?) than de-cluttering Windows (which is a sisyphean task by itself).
I'm not trying to push my hobbies on her, but I want her to learn technology in an environment free of the ads and other garbage that come with Windows and (to a lesser extent) macOS. I want her to learn what the computer is doing and not treat it like magic.
I'm terrified by iPads, I don't want her to think that consumption and pay-to-win games are all thats out there.
Overall, Win11 is, in my opinion, the second best OS Microsoft ever released, the best one being the venerable NT4.
But this is true that when installing it, there is some annoying cleaning work to be done, and this is clearly not good, especially for a -professional- tool.
I don't have time for this now, but I plan to migrate everything on a good Linux distro at some point.
My wife (not a tech person, far from it) used Ubuntu for ages until recently when she went back to the corporate world and was forced to use a Windows laptop from corporate.
Holy Jeebus, she would complain the whole eight hours of her work for about 2 or 3 months, at about the time they send her a macbook.
> I want him to be able to dig deeper. To explore. To try things out, misconfigure, crash, fix, and re-install. To get a feeling for how things work below the surface and how they do not work. To learn how to type fast and efficiently. To create things. Maybe, one day, even to learn how to code if he's interested.
Just get him a Linux, all above and so much more to learn and benefit from in the future.
Dont the big money makers hire psychologists to help them figure out how to 'drive user engagement'?
I feel like there is a difference between letting your kid browse through a library that contains the anarchist cookbook and letting your kid loose in a casino which I think maps to old internet/new internet. Old internet had dangerous information but individuals tended to be treated as an end in themselves, new internet tends to treat individuals as a means to an end.
I should be able to stop there, but I understand that if you never really gave Linux a shot, or you tried one distro once and gave up when the first thing broke, then you didn't get a chance to learn anything about Linux at all. If that's you, try Linux Mint next time. It's a good beginner distro, you won't break it easily, you will be able to google solutions easily and after a few months you will have learned enough to try other distros. It's important to start with a stable beginner distro to have the "things that work on linux desktop" benchmark.
Here's another thing you need to know about Linux: The look and feel of your Linux desktop is not locked-in. All those reviews you read about a Linux distro that talked about the look or feel, are actually just misleading. The look and feel are distro-independent for the most part.
Linux desktops are as customizable as you want them to be [1], or as little as you want them to be. GNOME and KDE are not the only game in town, XFCE is also a solid out-of-box minimalist experience which is very much like old-windows. If you want to boost productivity, tiling managers are waiting for you. You can also install all of them at once and switch at the login screen. Even the login screen is something you can customise or swap out.
For those times I find the following tools really useful.
But like the article says... its is hard to trust a company that build all this adware crap into my OS in the first place. =P
* O&O ShutUp10++ – Free antispy tool for Windows 10 and 11 || https://www.oo-software.com/en/shutup10
(I turn all the recommend options off, and then re-enable Clipboard History.)
* GitHub - StevenBlack/hosts: Consolidating and extending hosts files from several well-curated sources. Optionally pick extensions for porn, social media, and other categories. || https://github.com/StevenBlack/hosts
(And if you block things at the host level, remember to disable DNS Caching.)
* How to disable Windows 10 DNS Cache services || https://social.technet.microsoft.com/Forums/windows/en-US/a0...
* Wise Program Uninstaller - Uninstall, Remove or Force Uninstall Programs Completely || https://www.wisecleaner.com/wise-program-uninstaller.html
Yes, having to remove the adware is obnoxious but anything you use nowadays needs to be sanitized for kids and that includes Ipads. I'm just glad there are some built in ways to do that.
Just look at many Android phones and how something like Facebook can't even be permanently removed...
The problems started with Windows 7 when at some points the updates became obfuscated and mandatory to push "telemetry" aka data snooping. Before that phoning home was considered spyware and a sin.
I run Pro versions on all my machines and don't tend to have this blot. Is that it? I pay $49 more and get Windows without any of this crap? Sign me up.
Get a Framework laptop and install NixOS on it. Let him learn Linux while having the wonderful rollback capabilities that NixOS gives you. Let him enjoy tons of games via Proton. Done.
This is infuriating, even as an anti-social adult who has no use for them and actively wants to demote them.
News on search bar cannot be defended though.
But this is an article about product, and not technology, and I have to say I agree with him. The reason I am a Windows fan boy is because I grew up with the same experience. Though Windows has a reputation for being closed source and predatory, its association with games made it much more of a hacking toy for me growing up than any *nix-based system ever did.
However, the last iteration seems to be moving closer and closer to the tablet-UX world that modern product designers want us to be in on every device. Monetizing our intent is more lucrative than serving pre-existing demand.
I used to think their monopoly was a convenient positive since all applications n such would work, but this has proven woefully wrong.
(ameliorated.io)
- do a clean install via usb from the freely available official installers.
- create/login with microsoft account (yes, you must. this is fine).
- run hellzerg/optimizer and check every option.
- avoid entering sensitive information aside from what’s needed (steam/epic credentials, msft account).
for serious work, arch with any windowing setup can be installed on a second ssd.
separate disk makes dual boot easy since you just choose disk via bios boot options.
alpine unfortunately doesn’t have nvidia drivers yet.
Windows 11 has a fuckload of problems and is objectively a step or 12 backwards in terms of configurability, but this article doesn't really sell the problems very well IMO.
Doesn't Group Policy only work in Pro, which costs $100 to upgrade to? Even if you're rich enough to afford that without thinking twice, do you really want to reward Microsoft with more money for their bad behavior?
I cant be bothered to upgrade to pro or linux as the machine is just a host for vmware horizons but lets see when the first major update happens.
It'll live on in corporate environments and XBoxes.
I mean, you never could trust, and earlier the security was much worse, yet for some rose-tinted-glasses reason Windows was alive
Profound, truly.
This is of course completely forgetting the era when every prebuilt would ship with crapware, completely omitting the fact that via giveaways on places like GoG and EGS, children have access to more free games in one year than I was bought in my entire childhood and completely forgetting that there are more mature, free options to master a craft on your computer than ever before if you are so inclined to do so (blender, godot, unreal engine, unity, krita, visual studio, etc..) (not to mention a rich ecosystem of help for all of these, and normalized services like the internet generally that is cheap enough to be ubiquitous).
This guy evidently didn't ever know what it was like to grow up as a kid with computers, to be stuck with stock windows XP and a handful of games you had played to absolute death, with no means and parents who wouldn't buy any tool or app on the internet as it was inconceivable to do so, dicking around with MS Paint as the image editor of last resort, with big dreams and no prospects. I became merely familiar with computers as I was left alone with them for long enough to break several of them out of boredom. Meanwhile, I learned crafts (coding, 3D modelling, etc.) through my schooling, particularly university and an internship.
Windows basically hasn't changed, is the reality. We killed computing as a race through Android and IOS. Kids today aren't even spending time with computers anymore. That's the problem. The stab at TikTok here hides an underlying unspoken critique that such apps have sucked out attentions so completely that people aren't thinking about what they run on anymore. This article completely misses the point.
This was a clean Windows install, not one that came from an OEM. Clean Window installs at least used to be exactly that: they came with nothing but Windows.
How did the author even get a windows 11 install since they claim they have not used windows since version 8.
Will any win8 laptop even support an upgrade to 11? I doubt it.
Why not get linux running on the old laptop. Mint likely installs just fine.
I'm not saying win 11 is great and frankly none of the systems I have will even install it as they do not meet the requirements just that I find the set up to be sus.
From Microsoft? https://www.microsoft.com/software-download/windows11
The blog post doesn't say it was old. Did you misread So far, I have only used it a couple of times to debug old software I wrote long ago that needed some fixes ?
I agree with the article too. Windows is dead.