Your question also assumes the point that police are useful for dealing with murderers, which is not a point I'll cede uncontested.
Policing, because it's founded on the initiation of violence, is immoral.
Mature people can solve problems without resorting to violence. We can solve the problem of others being willing to do violence to us, more easily without a police agency, than with a police agency.
If you or I wanted the freedom to do harm to others, the best route for both of us would be to go join a local police force because they have immunity for the crimes that they commit against citizens.