The problem, as usual, is in how exactly words like "subjective", "experience", and "conscious" are defined. If you have a particular detailed definition for "quacking" and a test for it and an entity passes the test, then
by that definition, it quacks. Words like "conscious" are notoriously nebulous and slippery, and so it's better to use the particular attributes in question.
If we could all agree on a particular definition for "consciousness" and a running video game fits that definition, then, like it or not, it's conscious. But it does not mean that it must now also have a slew of other attributes just because conscious humans have them.
(edit: 10 hours later and ninja'ed by 1 minute, of course)