You can create strategies that return well above the market average. But there are caveats:
* You have to know something nobody else knows. The moment a strategy becomes public it stops being effective. By very definition, everybody can't be reaping well above market average... And there is a huge number of very, very smart and very, very motivated people backed by very, very large pools of money thinking about this problem.
* Ability to test strategies on past data is very limited. When you come up with a thousand strategies and find out one of them works very well with historical data -- that's exactly what you found. A strategy that works with historical data -- not necessarily with future trading conditions. Also at some point your trading starts affecting the market and that cannot be simulated with historical data.
For anybody thinking about investing their own money I can highly recommend ignoring any complex financial products and just buy shares of companies that you think are going to be doing well in the future, that you think are undervalued at the moment and you have knowledge and experience to understand their business. Please, do yourself a favour and read "The Snowball: Warren Buffett and the Business of Life".