I don't think an intelligence needs to be human, and it should be physically possible to create an intelligence which is synthetic. But in order to call the intelligence "general", and to rely on it for the purposes that designation implies, it would need to be able to successfully navigate the world, which requires access to that world and the use of the world as its own model, rather than the much simpler and coarser intermediary of text. In order to claim that an LLM can fully navigate the world after being trained on pure text, we would have to believe that all our writings across history have exhausted what there is to say about the world. This is not to say an LLM cannot be useful for some purposes, but there will be key ways in which they fail because they have no sense of meaning or what the world is like. Whether consciousness is required to solve this I don't know, but we simply haven't begun to approach a system that can meaningfully address the world as a world.