Publicly traded company should pay a small fee to SEC each year and they be responsible to hire auditors, for everyone. Or even better, market bid for auditors with incentives for finding irregularities.
With the current line up of incentives, auditors merely ensures any fraud are slightly better hidden.
Read up on regulations, it helps!
Is it? The incentives are not going to be aligned so far as the auditing companies are hired by the company being audited. It doesn't matter how many auditing company there is and the division of labor within.
Think of lobbyists, there are many different flavor of lobbyists, some might even be against the others. They distribute events, campaign finances and other things to legislators and as we know recently even certain members of judiciary. A bad idea in general in terms of the incentives at play.