It feels that's exactly what you did though. Pick a favored feature and declare that people not doing it predominantly that way are wrong.
> if it’s truly universal as Christianity claims.
Even if they believe that you should love the sinner I don't see where their traditions say they should lay down and let themselves be victimized because they can't regulate people they "love".
> “true” Christian, sometimes coupled with a “holier than thou” attitude. (Obviously generalizing centuries of history here)
Those centuries of history led to here, where in a country founded largely by Christians on Christian principles, you're allowed to say you don't think any of them are doing right. And you and I - total heathens, receive no threats, no hate.