with healthcare you always have to think about bad faith operators because there is zero transparency and no free market there.
with healthcare you always have to think about bad faith operators because there is zero transparency and no free market there.
In the US, the fire department shows up first and administers first aid. Private transport to the hospital is arranged after that if needed.
The problem is all the advance-fee bullshit. You're billed $1000 per minute starting with your occupation of a gurney, and that doesn't guarantee you will receive any sort of treatment once you get to the hospital. If you're not destined for a trauma ward, you'll sit in a room for six hours, be discharged without even a diagnosis (or the lolworthy "mild concussion"), and have incurred a debt equal to the cost of a new car for the experience.
These days, you don't even get a bottle of Oxy as a consolation gift-- you get nothing.
It's exploitative even when good faith operators are involved.
$10k for an ambulance ride? Is there any documentation for that claim, or is it just hyperbole?
According to the San Francisco Fire Department[0], an ambulance ride is ~$2400 (which includes lifesaving services), plus $46/mile[1.61km].
By my calculation, an ambulance would need to transport a patient ~165 miles (266km) to make an ambulance ride cost $10k.
For some perspective, It's ~160 miles from San Francisco to Fresno[1].
I'd expect that San Francisco EMTs don't deliver patients to Fresno, or even outside the San Francisco city limits[2]. Since San Francisco is 46.9 sq miles (121 sq km) in area, a $10k ambulance ride is incredibly unlikely at best.
N.B: I do not live in the Bay Area. It took less than 30 seconds to confirm the costs above via DDG. Not sure how GP (and others) came up with a number 400% higher.
[0] https://sf-fire.org/services/ambulance-billing
[1] https://www.distancecalculator.net/
[2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nota_bene
Edit: Added Nota Bene[2].
Don't believe me? Here's what happened right here in SF when a bicyclist with a broken arm was taken to the local public hospital, SF General:
"A few months later, Dang got a bill for $24,074.50. Premera Blue Cross, her health insurer, would only cover $3,830.79 of that — an amount that it thought was fair for the services provided. That left Dang with $20,243.71 to pay, which the hospital threatened to send to collections in mid-December."
> came up with a number 400% higher.
A moment with a calculator would show you that the number GP uses is 300% higher, not 400% :)
https://fortune.com/recommends/banking/57-percent-of-america...
https://www.vox.com/policy-and-politics/2019/1/7/18137967/er...
I didn't say there weren't problems with the system, or that most folks (let alone homeless folks) could afford such things, but 400% more than the published cost? That's hyperbolic and, more importantly, incredibly imprecise.
I see you disagree with that. I agree that you disagree with me. Have a lovely day.
Edit: removed extraneous text.
In common USA English, use of a figure like "10K" suggests imprecision - it's a magnitude of order ballpark, a gesture at the logarithmic scale.
This convention is useful because it's easy to remember a rough ballpark, but precise figures are going to quickly get muddied in details.
It seems strange to complain about imprecision when someone has already clearly indicated that they're talking about a rough estimate.
Really? As a life-long resident of the US, native US English speaker, and the child of a native US English speaker and a long-time resident of the US from another English-speaking country (UK) (both with post-baccalaureate degrees), I never heard that from anyone except you.
Not teachers in primary or secondary school, nor in college. Nor have I seen that in any of the many usage guides I've read over the past half-century or so.
Yes, "Forty days" in the Abrahamic[0] tradition is meant to be imprecise (i.e., meaning "a long time"), but the bible/torah/quran aren't guides to modern English, are they?
Perhaps you could enlighten this American ignoramus as to the correctness of US English idiomatic phrasing in this light. It would be most appreciated.
[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Abrahamic_religions
Edit: Clarified prose.
Unfortunately social rules like this usually aren't well documented. It's mostly a statistics thing: very few calculations produce an exactly even result, so more often than not someone has rounded things off.
If you want to get really fancy you can start using context and tone to further infer whether someone is throwing out a ballpark estimate or a precise number, but that's well beyond the scope of a HN comment
Exactly my point. And even if I wanted to, there's wasn't any tone or context to draw on -- just a flat assertion.
I'd add that, at least to me, a "ballpark" figure would be something reasonably close to an actual value e.g., $25 ballpark vs. $27.99. In the case to which I replied, it was more like "ballpark" $25, actual $9.99. Which "ain't the same fuckin' ballpark, it ain't the same league, it ain't even the same fuckin' sport."[0]
[0] with apologies to Quentin Tarantino.
Edit: Added an additional thought and some context.
Here[1] is an article on the top stories on HN right now where a couple was charged 200k for a rabies shot.
Posted prices here in the US are complete bullshit, as any medical code transcriber could tell you, or indeed anyone who's been to a US hospital and had to pay out of pocket.
I once went to the emergency room at 1am. It was almost empty, no one walking the floors, but still took them 4 hours to get to me.
They never checked my vitals or my weight, the doctor looked down my throat with a wooden stick, gave me one generic 200mg ibuprofen and sent me on my way.
My bill was $3500.
Their reasoning when I fought it? 'we only have very generalized codes and that's how we determine what to charge.
Literally did nothing but waste my time and charged me 3500 for the privilege.
I told them they wouldn't see a dime and I'd happily see them in court over it (no idea if I could even take them to court but I was beyond pissed).
Bill was dropped to 250,which to me was still outrageous for a freaking ibuprofen (dollar store knockoff brand to boot!).
Over one dollar per milligram of OTC medicine.
This was now 15 years ago and the prices have done nothing but increase since.
Yes, medical billing in the US is hopelessly opaque. And I've had an even more egregious experience[0] myself.
However, that $250 wasn't just for the ibuprofen and tongue depressor. It's for the physical plant, infrastructure and other operating expenses as well. Although the largest portion of that is likely the cost for the time of highly-trained personnel (nurses, doctors, etc.).
How much do you earn in an hour? No. Don't tell me. I don't care.
But I'm sure it's more than zero, right? Would you work for zero dollars an hour?
If not, why are you ignoring the costs of paying hospital personnel?
Not sure why you went to an emergency room. Those are for, wait for it...emergencies. Was it an actual emergency? If not, they should have charged you even more.
[0] A physician to whom I was referred posited (incorrectly) that a skin lesion might be infected with MRSA[1] and insisted that I go to the hospital for testing and immediate IV antibiotics. I reluctantly (as I -- correctly -- believed that wasn't the case) did so. I was in the hospital for three days (the length of time -- at least they claimed it took that long -- to test for MRSA), after which time I was told (shocking...not!) that I was not, in fact, infected with MRSA and discharged. I received a bill for something like $100 and an "explanation of benefits" (EOB) from my insurance company. The "total cost" listed on the EOB was ~$12,000. Out of curiosity, I perused the detail and found that I was being "charged" for being in two hospital rooms at the same time (a neat trick, I wish I could replicate it) as well as having had a Pap smear[2], despite not (ever) having a cervix.
I complained to the insurance company that there was obvious fraud going on. They responded that I shouldn't worry my pretty little head about it because I wasn't paying anyway. That made me even angrier and I demanded that this be investigated and addressed. A few days later, I was involved in a conference call with the insurer and someone from the billing department of the hospital in question. The insurer and the hospital went back and forth (performatively, I soon found) about billing codes, but when I pressed them on how I could possibly have had a pap smear when I don't have a female reproductive system, they finally fessed up and told me that the contract between the hospital and the insurer capped hospital stays/services at $500/day, and that the stuff in the EOB was complete bullshit.
Just as the $3500 on your bill was complete bullshit. But $250 actually seems reasonable for an emergency room visit. Even with health insurance, I'm subject to a $150 co-payment for emergency room visits -- just for walking in the door and signing in.
[1] https://www.mayoclinic.org/diseases-conditions/mrsa/symptoms...
[2] https://www.mayoclinic.org/tests-procedures/pap-smear/about/...
The "rules" of medicine are often quirky and very frequently frustrating (to both patients and doctors) - but they're rarely random.
Yeah. The doctor who visited this horror on me seems to have been a really bad doctor. Which is also why I changed GPs after this because he recommended this moron.
I'm not a physician, but in 2008 when this was happening, I asked about oral antibiotics and was told they were ineffective for MRSA. That may have been ignorance or a lie. Or, perhaps things have changed in the past 15 years. I have no idea.
Prior to hospitalization, he'd prescribed a topical sulfa drug (which, unknown to me until then I was allergic to) which made things much, much worse. In fact, I have permanent damage and discoloration to the skin on my leg. And I developed hives on the palms of my hands and the soles of my feet. It was a disaster -- but that wasn't the doctor's fault -- I didn't know I was allergic.
After that debacle, I went to see a vascular specialist (the other guy was a "wound care" doctor), who suggested a compression stocking[0]. The lesion was completely healed in five days.
Now I take a much more active approach when I have medical issues, having learned (the hard way) that I need to be my own best counsel when it comes to my health. That includes research, asking questions, making sure I have the relevant information to make appropriate medical decisions for myself.
[0] https://health.clevelandclinic.org/what-you-should-know-abou...
Edit: added the missing link.
Yes I am paid for the work I do, but I wouldn't expect to be paid for the work I am supposed to but dont do.
warning this will be a bit graphic/gross
A bit more context on my event: I had an abscess on the upper part of my jaw that had my entire face swollen and a fever of 102+ when I went in. I was shaking all over with chills and sweating like I was in a sauna.
They let me sit there in agony and never checked my vitals. Not my temperature, not my blood pressure- nothing.
I begged them to lance it, anything. Ice for the swelling, even. Nothing.
It was so bad after being in the hospital 4+ hours I went home and the abscess grew so bad it drained out the bottom of my tooth root.
I could very well have died. And they used a fucking tongue depressor and handed me a 200mg ibuprofen.
That was why I was so upset with the bill.
I get it there's doctors and infra to pay for, but not for doing nothing, especially when we had free clinics in that city that could have helped me had it been normal business hours.
I've paid thousands for stiches and complained, but at least I got the stiches, so I shut up and paid. I had slag get in my eye that had to be dug out with a needle. My eye was numbed, they removed the shards (the slag cooled when it hit my tears and shards were embedded in my eye). That cost me a grand total of 750. The penicillin eye drops they prescribed? 500 before I think it was goodrx where they have deals on scripts and I think I got them for 50.
Point being they make this up as they go and there's zero reason for it to ever change.
Edit for more color- the abscesses event was at an ER in a hospital that most definitely had the capability to at least get me to an actual doctor in the hospital side rather than keep me in ER. And this was before the prevalence of these new Emergency centers as I'd have gladly gone to one of those instead.
I'm sorry you had to go through that as well.
That's awful care. I had a similar situation (not in my mouth, but on the nape of my neck. A sebaceous cyst that was infected and swollen.
This was only a couple years ago and I actually went to one of those "urgent care" centers. They took one look and said "nothing we can do, you should go to the emergency room." For which they charged my insurance company $1800 (of which I was billed ~$200 -- money those assholes will never get, I might add). So those folks aren't necessarily the best choice either.
So I did go to the emergency room and was ushered into an exam room within an hour. They did examine it and me and actually got the on-call resident from the surgery department to open it up and drain it.
It helped a lot, but they did a half-assed job and I had to go back for more cutting/draining. Even now, the sac that the sebaceous cyst grew from was not removed (GRRR!) and I will (probably this year) have it removed and the site closed up properly.
That's much better than your experience, but still not that good.
It was still a few thousand dollars, although my insurance paid most of it.
But whatever hospital you went to should be named and shamed, because they didn't do (provide adequate care) what they were supposed to (and billed for) do. That was awful and you have every right to be angry -- but it's almost certainly not worth legal action -- and more's the pity.
The bigger issue (IMHO) is less about quality of care (although as we've both experienced, that can be quite variable -- and that's certainly an issue) is the business model around health care in the US.
Which makes accessing health care and understanding the costs much more difficult than it should be.
I'm all for a single-payer system or, as they have in Germany (at least IIUC), private insurers that are non-profit by law.
Unfortunately, that's unlikely to happen here -- as the insurance (and healthcare) lobby will push hard to maintain their profits -- sucking resources from the system that could instead be used to provide better care.
And the current model also encourages consolidation, which harms small communities the most (see this joke[0] for context), since there isn't a whole lot of profit to be made, and hospitals have expensive infrastructure requirements.
[0] source: https://motd.ambians.com/quotes.php/name/freebsd_fortunes/to...
On his first day as a bus driver, Maxey Eckstein handed in receipts of $65.
The next day his take was $67. The third day's income was $62. But on the
fourth day, Eckstein emptied no less than $283 on the desk before the
cashier.
"Eckstein!" exclaimed the cashier. "This is fantastic. That
route never brought in money like this! What happened?"
"Well, after three days on that cockamamie route, I figured business would
never improve, so I drove over to Fourteenth Street and worked there.
I tell you, that street is a gold mine!"
Edit: Fixed formatting. Removed extraneous text.For example, when my family were involved in a car crash on the freeway in Los Angeles some years ago, even though the local fire department arrived at the scene within minutes, their paramedics did not. My two kids were taken to hospital in separate private ambulances. $6k each.
The free market could incentivize bad faith operators even more because of the greater potential of the profit motive. Free market doesn't necessarily mean greater transparency or ethics.