Dismissing someone of Roamer's stature in his field of expertise has to be peak HN.
There is nothing wrong with disagreeing with even the most respected of experts, history has proven they can be wrong often.
Simply ignoring someone because "I don't know who this is" is generally a bad idea, and even more ridiculous when that person does in fact have a well known reputation.
I disagree with the rigor of the analysis. I don’t have any strong opinions on the takeaways.