Why do we even bother making indie games?
old.reddit.com
old.reddit.com
I went to GDC last month solely to attend business/marketing talks as I have a couple game projects in early stages and I’ve been wondering whether I wanted to commit the effort and money to see them through production.
Everyone there seemed to be unanimous that as far as marketing goes, the only thing that matters right now is TikTok. Posting a 10 second video once a week - even if it’s just a silly recording of your dev process - can and will net you hundreds of thousands of views, all through the organic “For You” page. None of the marketing people who spoke had good things to say about Instagram/Twitter and the general takeaway was to not waste your time with them.
So many indie game developers want to work on their project alone in a cave until they release it to the world and everyone unanimously declares it to be a work of genius and they sell 10 million companies. Every once in a blue moon that does happen, but if you’re investing years of your life into making a game, do you really want to take that gamble? There are people who have made it their specialty to figure out how to get your game in front of people, can you really afford to not listen to them?
Florent, if you’re reading this, hire a marketing person. (if you already have one, fire them). With 2 award winning games under your belt this is where your problem is.
Many subreddits (maybe even reddit as a whole) have rules against self-promotion. I don't see why they need to link to the games. They're easy enough to find, and those who are interested can easily find them (I just did)
The indie dev subreddit has no rule against making your game name a clickable link. (The whole point of the subreddit is kind of self promotion for indie devs…)
Aside: one problem is that from looking at [1] is that I have no idea what kind of game this is; I get that it's mostly story-based, but is this a point-and-click adventure? Or more like Gone Home? Or something else? "3D visual novel" almost sounds like a movie in a .exe format. I feel like I'd be spending €19 for a cat in a bag.
To my understanding, it is a stretch to call them video games at all. More like “Oops! All Cutscenes”.
> Rock Paper Shotgun’s Bestest best good. 9/10 on Pocket Tactics, 8/10 on Gamespew and 8.5 on Well Played good
... Don't get me wrong, I love RPS, but anyone using written reviewers as a yardstick is operating in a different decade.
VNs are niche enough, trying to compete with the established heavy-hitters is going to be an uphill struggle. That they saw previous success is a fluke and depends which way the wind is blowing on any given day. Now isn't a great time to sell anything with economic uncertainty, especially as they self-published. Publishers frequently make or break indie games, and clearly it made previous attempts. Lesson learned is that maybe they need a publisher and don't yet yield enough clout or budget to make something a success numbers-wise. Maybe reaching out to a publisher to do a remastered version in a few years might make sense to them, I've seen a few indies do well with a rerelease.
Still I do have regrets and keep promising myself I'll make the time someday... once I'm financially secure. Props to them for taking risks on hard sell products. It enriches us all.
And by sweet spot I mean both business efficiency and quality. They arent just burning money and melting devs' faces for a soulless rehash like many AAAs, but they can stay above water better than an indie (especially with a big "hands off" backer like many have). And I think that sweet spot will be even more pronounced in the coming years since AAAs are losing many of their advantages, like high budget VA/asset making being replaced with AI, and fully bespoke engines being more of a liability than an advantage.