The fundamental problem is that businesses are focused on profits rather than employee satisfaction or producing quality products. Unless that is changed any regulations nibbling around the edges will just end up in a cat and mouse game between then businesses and the government.
"Duck typing unions"
What many companies with rigid pay bands do to handle this in practice, and what would undermine what you are proposing, is to continuously invent new titles/bands if the salary requirements change too quickly. I've seen companies that had hundreds of different titles for tech peoples for exactly this reason, creating new ones if the market salary moved too quickly.
It isn't just about how much people get paid. A policy of leveling up everyone automatically would massively increase the financial risk of the company, which has enormous downstream costs in terms of valuation, ability to borrow, etc.
Just for fun, I'm going to poke at this:
> ... [T]here is no practical way to budget for randomly giving most people large pay raises throughout the year
I think we can find examples of labor markets that do expose more "upside" to workers, and then see how the "downside" is handled in those instances. Contractors (1099 in the U.S.) comes immediately to mind... They typically make a lot higher rate (I'd guess around double although I often hear lower numbers, which I personally think is too low to make it a good deal) but must pay their full income tax (instead of half), their full health insurance, and are subject to be the first to be let go when the company needs to cut costs, i.e. higher risk of termination, so must be able to save for time between jobs.
"Boom" economies can drive labor prices very high. I think we've been seeing this in temporary nursing lately, where the wages go very high, especially if you're willing to travel or locate in remote places. Of course, the "boom" doesn't last forever, and eventually wages will stabilize at a lower rate. Note again that these temporary positions.
(So far it seems like the higher wages come with more "risk" put onto the laborer.)
I'm sure there are some even better examples.
It’s very rare to see companies actually doing this. They usually don’t at all, and when they do it’s often so vague that the bonus is basically entirely at the superior’s discretion with no tangible basis.
I think it’s fair that the people who risked the most to create the company get a significant chunk of the profit but why should employees be reduced to leftover crumbs in the best case and typically nothing at all beyond their poorly negotiated salaries that didn’t track inflation over the years?
In a good year there is profit to spread around anyway, bad years there is nothing extra.
I don’t know how that would work in our insane industry through where it’s a valid business model to hemorrhage money for years (decades even) without any real path to profitability. But I’m sure we can find a solution, as founders rarely live in poverty past a certain company size.
And I’m not talking about the joke that equity is in most cases where it’s barely worth the paper it’s granted on.
How does that work?
I don’t think this is a revolutionary idea, that’s how traders bonuses are paid, that’s how the variable part of CEO pay is calculated. Why not for employees too who frankly contribute the bulk of the work that generate said profits (and sometimes do so despite the managers and execs best efforts to lost the company money but get bonuses anyway)
I think very rigid predefined pay bands are very common for large companies, at least in Canada.