Q: is there firm evidence for long covid that excludes these possibilities?
Q: is there firm evidence for long covid that excludes these possibilities?
I think the skeptical take is neither of these things. What you've described is more of a cynical contrarian take.
The skeptical take is not "there's no long covid" but "there MIGHT not be long covid".
And it's not ~"people are faking or imagining"~ it's "lots of people develop weird health problems every day that never get explained, which many will now point to as long covid, which makes it super hard to know if long covid exists".
You could say the same about any other sickness that doesnt have obvious externally visible symptoms, and you’d still not be making an argument.
So why are you also suggesting they are making one?
They clearly presented a skeptical take as an option, then asked a question about whether a better alternative exists. More charity in interpretation would be useful for you.
If I say "here is option X" and make no suggestion that it is my position or advocate it as fact, why would you then try to force it to become my position? Analysis of possible positions is allowed and encouraged.
What's the difference between a hypothesis and an argument?
This should be obvious...
It’s also not a requirement that you exclusively argue your own personal view point. And of course appearing impartial to an argument via language like “to play devil’s advocate, etc.” is a common device used to introduce an argument you may believe, or want other to believe, without being inflammatory.
If that is what you're trying to say, then I would reply that both the history of medicine, as well as the sheer amount of known (to say nothing of unknown) blind spots within current medical practice point toward a more credulous approach toward these sufferers, if you want to believe the truly sick significantly more often than you want to catch the fakers.
The data from the St Louis Fed do look concerning.
Civilian Labor Force - With a Disability, 16 to 64 Years, Men: https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/LNU01076955 Civilian Labor Force - With a Disability, 16 to 64 Years, Women: https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/LNU01076960
There are fewer SSA workers since the start of the pandemic and often, it takes multiple years for a disabled person to receive disability, often requiring resources that they do not have to complete the process.