I think my response would be two words and the second one would be off.
I think my response would be two words and the second one would be off.
It's actually deliberately criminal as I read it. "Hey, I trojaned some code and got it downloaded onto your company's systems! Please pay me a bug bounty!" is 100% isomorphic to extortion.
The issue here is that the submit actually attacked live systems, instead of just reporting on the possibility of malicious library code.
...which is something everyone already knows about, and thus why he couldn't get paid. You don't get paid for actually hacking systems either!
There is no credible threat here. In addition to the above points, if attacks were made by exploiting these facts, the author, having raised the issue in the first place, would become a person of interest in any investigation.
Notice that you are also taking the author at his word when you say he literally compromised live systems. To turn this into a case of extortion, you would have to go beyond that and invent a number of things that have not been said - and some highly implausible things at that, given the very public way in which this supposed extortion is being conducted.
Technically true. If this happened as described, it's criminal behavior. If he's lying, it's maybe not.
FWIW: explicit threats are not and never have been a requirement for prosecuting extortion crimes. I'm not sure where you are getting that.
And for your information, 'explicit' is not a synonym of 'credible'.