Larry Summers Warns of US Losing Influence as Other Powers Band Together
bloomberg.com
bloomberg.com
As for many Asian countries, faced with handling an often hostile China on their own and supporting U.S. policy as tacit allies, the choice is obvious and they definitely won't be jumping off the bandwagon. This definitely applies to South Korea and Japan, but it also applies to many other regional states that either hate or mistrust the Chinese. Among these, The Philippines, Malaysia, Indonesia, and Vietnam. Even India, a major power on its own, is leery of its neighbor and much more likely to side with the west.
As for much of Africa and parts of the Middle East, as another comment here said very well, they know where international force projection and boots on the ground can come from to support or hinder their own internal policies, and this makes them very leery of suddenly switching sides to China (Russia even less so, barely worth considering with very few exceptions).
Overall, the western system of international influence is still firmly in place and spearheaded by the U.S.. This comes with many flaws, no doubt, bit if I had to choose between a world with U.S.dominance and the same power level being held by any other of the really major powers, particularly China, the choice is obvious.
I've heard people say US is the world police / places depend on the US for defense, but that doesn't have to be a forever truth, right? Especially with the situation in Ukraine, it seems like someone must be considering / forecasting this.
The US isn't attaching Europe any time soon, the same holds for China. All the EU really needs is a strong enough force to handle all other players, and with that they are no longer dependent on the US. I get that costs a fair amount of money and the US is providing its services for "free". However, if the EU was motivated enough, this doesn't seem outlandish.
I guess what I'm saying is that the EU doesn't seem dependent on the US, it just doesn't want to spend the money and time. With the right motivation, they might change their minds. This is different than the situation in, for example, Armenia. They could not muster a military force strong enough if they tried, so they dependent on Russia.
After all the EU has a larger, well educated population and enough of a young population created by immigrants to easily staff such a military power system. It also has the economic and technical capacity to do so, since as a whole it has an economy roughly the size of the U.S. economy.
Thus none of these are major obstacles. Neither is geography an insurmountable difficulty, since the EU has only one major land border to defend, in the east and even that against a set of countries that are much poorer, weaker and much less populated than the EU/NATO states (despite their larger landmass).
Raw resources could be a problem for the Union, because the EU has them to a much lesser degree than Russia or the U.S., but this could be partly solved by support from overseas (The U.S. for starters), and even partial protection of these seaborne imports by the globally powerful U.S. navy, which would likely be friendly. Also, the sophistication of the EU economy is such that it could likely do more with fewer materials than Russia, even if access to them became a problem.
Thus with all the above covered, the biggest difficulty is in cohesion instead:
The U.S. consists of 50 states and many different ethnic groups, but they almost universally and firmly submit to the central power and direction of the federal government along clearly , historically defined and well respected lines. They also have a long and mostly uniform history of getting along with each other as parts of this national whole (taking aside the 4 years of the Civil War, 162 years ago) On top of this, most people across the whole of the U.S. strongly identify with being American and defending their country. This by the way applies even to the first generation children of most immigrants, which is an impressive showing for the value assigned to American culture and liking it.
The EU on the other hand consists of 27 mostly distinct countries, each with its own unique political, legal, social and economic history and attending sense of identity based on these. Neither the governments of these countries or their people consider themselves European first in the way Americans do. Getting them all to join together militarily in the same way as the U.S. would thus be incredibly hard, considering past animosities, the above-mentioned qualities and of course, simple resistance to economic sacrifice. Sure, EU member nations and their people superficially play along with the practices of supranational government while its convenient, but this could go out the window the minute it becomes really hard or dangerous. In a military context, much more so, and especially in a war scenario outside of the purely, urgently defensive.
The key bit that seems to be missed here is that fewer and fewer people see us as being on the right side of history and it's not "our commitment to democracy" driving them away. It's painful to read someone say something so obtuse.
Take a random middle east/African country, if a civil war breaks out tomorrow, how many countries do you think are willing to singlehandedly commit troops to turn the tide for their favored party? Aside from the French and the Russians, most other countries are happy to send only supplies, not actual boots on the ground. No amount of free infrastructure and bribes can replace actual hard power.
The Brics countries are nominally non-aligned and none of the global south is willing to stick their necks out for each other when things get hot. Alternate supply routes and logistics/currencies are only useful if they can be defended. There is no replacement for the US military as an instrument of global force projection. The allegedly great militaries of China and India spend all their time at home and the only border "conflicts" they participate in involves literal sticks and stones in the Himalayans. Those two make up more than a quarter of the human civilization and their military activity in terms of foreign adventure is terribly underwhelming. You are not a superpower if your hard power is only on paper.
I believe Canada just sent some people to Haiti.
Not by choice but by force.
The U.S. will absolutely not allow any foreign military bases or an other country to protect its own supply routes.
Some of it is. If the US didn't support democracy in HK and Taiwan, then the sentiment inside China would be less anti-US and more pro-US.
The US isn't a reliable supporter of anything but direct US interests, particularly in regards to private property. This means that it will always have a hard time having solid long-term relationships with peers of equal power, or maintaining respectful "we'll do X, you do Y" disagreements. We've gotten along with Europe and the English-speaking world because none of them really pose a significant challenge to the dance America calls. But we could barely make it through the length of WWII before deciding we couldn't coexist with the USSR.
Uncompetitive. Current admin needs to change course.