I had left the UK by then so I wasn't paying much attention to what went on, but when I did pay more attention when Brexit was rearing its head Cameron seemed like such a wanky toff it's hard to understand how his govt had not only got back in but were in a better position.
(Abbot is the most maligned person in UK politics; I believe someone did a survey of all hate mail (or email?) sent to the House of Commons, and found that a whole third of it was for her alone. I would simply not trust media-informed views of her, unfortunately)
Huh that is very easy to understand. There were two main reasons:
1. Labour had left the government essentially bankrupt, literally leaving the coalition a note that said "there's no money anywhere" iirc. The new government had come in and discovered the finances of the state had been utterly ruined. The numbers were stark and voters had accepted the argument that budget cutbacks were necessary to try and right the ship.
Labour had sort of accepted that this situation was true, but failed to take it seriously. Miliband supposedly had a minor meltdown after he tried to give a long speech without notes, and then realized only afterwards that he'd forgotten the entire section about the deficit. That was the number one issue in British politics at the time!
2. The EU had been building as a bigger and bigger problem over time. Voters were increasingly upset that their concerns on major policy areas like immigration were being systematically ignored by all the major parties, except for the eurosceptic wing of the Tories. Neither Labour nor the mainline Tories nor the Lib Dems wanted to tackle this problem. UKIP came along and started hoovering up votes from both left and right by promising a referendum on the EU. Cameron saw what was happening and decided he could end UKIP, win the election and also crush the eurosceptics by promising an EU referendum he was convinced he could win. That caused a whole lot of voters to abandon UKIP and vote Tory in the correct belief that Cameron would honor his promise. The rest is history.
I didn't know there was a building EU resentment (beyond the stupid stuff I'd heard growing up in the UK). I was living in Europe at the time. It all seems so bizarre.
Resentment against the EU had been building for years due partly to the totally incorrect initial claims made about immigration levels, and then the lack of interest/ability in controlling it. Even voters who weren't that affected by it saw that there were now real issues that affected local people which had effectively been removed from democracy and felt that was wrong. So there was a broad coalition being built by Farage, both the people who cared primarily about immigration levels and wage suppression of the working classes, and also those who cared about the constitutional issue it was exposing.
That's an odd framing of events considering Brown came in midway through 2007. Just before the 2008 GFC.
You make it sound like he went Brown went on a spending spree on a whim ... that isn't what happened. Any increased spending that took place when he became PM was easily within the scope of the UK economy. And considering National Debt was well managed until then (during a time when Brown was Chancellor), your recollection of what happened is wrong.
https://www.economicshelp.org/blog/334/uk-economy/uk-nationa...
And that is exactly the point being made. Brown was in charge when the economy entered a crisis and yet was too left wing to slam the brakes on government spending in response. Voters reacted accordingly.
Do you not remember bailing out the banks?
Emergency stimuli to keep the economy going from recession to depression?
Decreasing tax revenue as the economy entered recession?
And yet, you say Brown was too left wing to slam on the brakes on government spending? ... we would be finished as a nation if you were in charge.
It's just me and you. I'm sure no one else is reading this. So I'll just say. I'm quite confident you have no idea what you're talking about. Either you were too young at the time, no idea how the economy works (especially during a crisis) or ... let's leave it at that.
It doesn't matter why Brown spent so much money. What matters is that after he did so nobody in the Labour hierarchy adjusted to the new reality that they'd spent all the money, and they'd need to implement austerity via large budget cuts to try and reduce the suddenly massive deficit. The Conservatives did realize that, did make that argument, and the voters agreed with them. Which is the point I've been making all along.
BTW it's very rich that in a thread where I'm having to remind people about the issues in an election that only happened 13 years ago, you're claiming I'm too young to remember what happened at the time! The economy, Labour's claims to be competent at it "we have ended boom and bust" etc followed by their Labour's inability to seem serious about the deficit remained an issue for years. Don't you recall Miliband's doomed notes-free speech and his subsequent political exile? That was in 2014. Even years after losing to the coalition, they still didn't want to talk about cutting public sector spending and voters reacted accordingly:
https://www.theguardian.com/politics/2014/sep/24/ed-miliband...
There's an analysis by Labour supporters here:
https://labourlist.org/2010/05/why-labour-lost/
"People stopped trusting the party and they didn’t believe what it said about foreign wars, the state of the economy, reform of Parliament and public spending"
I'm not interested in the politics of why the voters voted they way they did. And your assertions on that are like picking a few leaves off a tree and saying that they are the reason the tree grows.
Your contention was that "Brown was too left wing to slam on the spending brakes".
My contention is that the chart I posted would have looked largely the same whichever party was in power. The only difference would have been the degree and speed of action. And it was this that Conservatives got wrong and which I think that Brown would have done better with. He wasn't a good PM, but he knew what mattered on the economy.
And you can run a clear line from the decisions that were made by the Conservatives at the time to where we are today. The mistakes made (David Cameron with Brexit, Austerity, and now political corruption and malaise) have effectively ruined the potential of Britain for decades to come.
I'm not here to defend Brown, but I do understand the position he was in. Anything else is political garbage.
>> I never understood why Miliband didn't win the 2015 election.
And so this thread is an attempt to explain that, by reference to Labour's legacy of not being willing to reduce public spending.
>> My contention is that the chart I posted would have looked largely the same whichever party was in power.
It might have done, but Brown didn't argue that. In the leadup to 2010 he argued that he would simply not increase it further, in contrast to the "savage cuts" planned by the Tories.
Brown just wasn't charismatic and he made some critical political timing errors. You can have one but you can't have both and he deserved to lose the election.
With the economy, however, he played a blinder and it's under-appreciated. The subsequent clowns have proven that. Brown's mistake was his desire to be PM.