> There is no hypothesis to test that disproves "an organism is alive when it can X and Y".
1. Metabolize 2. Homeostasis 3. Responds to stimuli 4. Growth 5. Reproduction
Never learned the list in school? It often includes "composed of cells", but that one might not make sense for xenobiology.
There are people who only believe in science, I guess, when it gives them the answers they were hoping for anyway.