Does this mean all Lisp code is good? :)
Does this mean all Lisp code is good? :)
Note that Codd's model is not Turing-complete, while all but the most trivial definitions of code lead to Turing-complete systems, hence the parenthetical most in my "data replaces (most) code". Data is easy, code is hard could be another way to state that.
We have experimented with such ideas, and we can report that they do significantly improve clarity and therefore productivity.
As an aside to a pg essay, I believe clarity is not the same as succinctness and as a corollary, succinctness does not imply productivity except in the somewhat trivial sense of ease of typing.
But when writing for others, abstractions kill clarity.
It's true in language too. You use fewer words explaining something to yourself than to others.
For example I can say to myself, "Our election are no different than high school elections (decided on popularity, not issues)."
It would be seen as heretical to most, and wrong to others. But I'd be sure that I'm right.
They can't see that behind that thought is long reflection on high school popularity, evolutionary psychology, and more things than I can recall.
Incidentally, Paul makes this same point in, It's the Charisma, Stupid. And while reading it I thought, "He's just saying that things don't change (after high school). What an elegant theory; Occam's razor at it's best."
The reverse can also be true, though; data "is" code, in that if you design a data structure sufficiently well, for example, the necessary code to work with it should be self-evident. (Interestingly, "data is code" is probably more characteristic of Forth and (in a very different way) the relational paradigm.)