Good point.
You'll have to failover to a different server, which brings you back to an automatic load balancing strategy.
Or to a manual load balancing strategy. What I have in mind is being able to easily re-direct users from one server to another using a simple CLI utility. This won't entirely eliminate downtime issues but it will (hopefully) mitigate effects to a manageable level.
In the era of cloud computing, downtime has become less of an issue.
This is one of those things that sounds _very simple_, but in practice is incredibly complicated.
I like attempting to simplify supposedly complicated issues. What I have in mind is simply counting the requests each server handles and using this as a simple measure to compare utilization. It's true that all requests are not equal but statistically, over time, with all servers being similar, the differences will tend to balance out.